Money, planning and life on the Coast

Retirement

Roth or Traditional? The California Answer for San Diego Savers in 2026

The decision turns on one comparison: the combined tax rate you avoid today against the rate you will pay later. In San Diego the second term depends on a pension, a balance, and whether you really leave the state.

What to take away

  • Traditional and Roth are mirror images at equal tax rates; the decision is today's combined marginal rate against retirement's, and California's 9.3% bracket begins at $70,606 of single taxable income.
  • A CalPERS, CalSTRS, SDCERS or military pension fills the low brackets in retirement, so public employees and career military usually come out ahead with Roth contributions.
  • Federal law bars California from taxing a former resident's retirement income, so a committed move to a no-tax state favors the traditional door; staying favors the Roth, and splitting hedges both.
  • The Roth's extra features favor it in close cases: more real money at the same limit, no RMDs, no effect on Medicare surcharges or Social Security taxation, and contributions accessible any time.
  • From 2026, catch-up contributions by workers over 50 with prior-year wages above $150,000 must be Roth; confirm the plan offers a Roth source.
  • Conversions in gap years, early retirement or after a move out of state turn traditional balances into Roth at the lowest rates available.
At a glance: the Roth versus traditional decision for a San Diego saver, 2026
Item Figure
Federal brackets, single, taxable income 10% to $12,400; 12% to $50,400; 22% to $105,700; 24% to $201,775; 32% to $256,225; 35% to $640,600; 37% above
Federal standard deduction $16,100 single; $32,200 married filing jointly
California brackets, single, taxable income (2025 schedule) 1% to $10,756; 2% to $25,499; 4% to $40,245; 6% to $55,866; 8% to $70,606; 9.3% to $360,659; 10.3% to $432,787; 11.3% to $721,314; 12.3% above
Combined marginal rate, single on $95,000 salary About 31.3% (22% federal plus 9.3% California)
Combined marginal rate, single on $180,000 salary About 33.3% (24% plus 9.3%)
401(k) limit $24,500; catch-up $8,000 at 50; $11,250 at 60 to 63
New in 2026 Catch-up contributions must be Roth for workers whose prior-year FICA wages exceeded $150,000
State tax on retirement income after leaving California None; federal law bars it
Required minimum distributions Traditional: from 73 (75 if born 1960 or later). Roth IRA: none; Roth 401(k): none from 2024

Every dollar a San Diegan saves for retirement goes through one of two doors. The traditional door, the pre-tax 401(k) or deductible IRA, skips tax now and pays it on the way out. The Roth door pays tax now and skips it on the way out. The arithmetic is symmetrical: $10,000 taxed at 30% and then grown is worth exactly what $10,000 grown and then taxed at 30% is worth. The whole decision therefore turns on one comparison, the tax rate you avoid today against the rate you will pay in retirement, and in California that comparison has a second term that most national guides handle badly: a state rate of 9.3% or more that applies now, applies later if you stay, and vanishes if you leave.

This guide works through the comparison for San Diego households: the rates, the pension and Social Security effects, the leave-or-stay question, the secondary advantages that tip close cases, the new 2026 rule on catch-up contributions, and a decision table by income and situation. It assumes the basics in the 401(k) guide and the Roth IRA guide.

The core arithmetic, once

Suppose a 35-year-old in the 24% federal and 9.3% California brackets has $10,000 of salary to save. Through the traditional door, the whole $10,000 goes in and grows at 7% for 30 years to $76,100; withdrawn at a combined 30% rate, it yields $53,300. Through the Roth door, tax of $3,330 is paid first, $6,670 goes in and grows to $50,800, withdrawn tax-free. The traditional door wins by $2,500 because the assumed retirement rate, 30%, was lower than today’s 33.3%. Reverse the rates, 30% now and 33.3% later, and the Roth wins by the same margin. At equal rates the two doors are identical.

Everything that follows is about estimating the two rates honestly, and about the handful of features that break the symmetry.

Your rate today

The rate that matters is the marginal rate, the tax on the last dollar, combined across federal and California. The quick way to find it: take gross salary, subtract the pre-tax 401(k) contribution, the standard deduction and any HSA or health premium deductions, and look up where the result falls in both schedules.

Combined marginal rates for common San Diego incomes, 2026 (standard deduction, no other adjustments)
Household Salary Federal bracket California bracket Combined
Navy E-5, single, BAH excluded $45,000 taxable pay 12% 6% 18%
Teacher, single, year 5 $78,000 22% 8% 30%
Nurse, single $98,000 22% 9.3% 31.3%
Engineer, single $165,000 24% 9.3% 33.3%
Two-income couple $230,000 24% 9.3% 33.3%
Two-income couple, both tech $380,000 32% 9.3% 41.3%
Physician, married $520,000 35% 10.3% 45.3%

Note that the California bracket thresholds are lower than the federal ones, so the state rate hits 9.3% at $70,606 of taxable income for a single filer, well before the federal rate reaches 24%. A San Diegan who thinks of themselves as “in the 22% bracket” is in a 31.3% bracket.

Your rate in retirement

This is the estimate that decides everything, and three things drive it.

The size of the traditional balance. Withdrawals from pre-tax accounts are ordinary income, and so are required minimum distributions, which a large balance forces whether the money is needed or not. A couple with $2 million in a traditional 401(k) at 75 must withdraw about $81,000 that year on the IRS table, on top of everything else.

Pensions and Social Security. A CalPERS, CalSTRS, SDCERS or military pension is ordinary income from the day it starts, and Social Security is up to 85% taxable federally (though exempt in California). A retired San Diego Unified teacher with a $60,000 CalSTRS pension and a spouse with $30,000 of Social Security already has about $85,000 of federal taxable income before touching savings; their 401(k) withdrawals land in the 22% bracket, and in California’s 9.3%, from the first dollar. For public employees and career military, the retirement rate is often as high as the working rate, which is the strongest case for Roth contributions during the career.

Where you live. Federal law bars any state from taxing the retirement income of a non-resident, including pensions and 401(k) and IRA withdrawals earned in that state. A San Diegan who retires to Nevada, Texas, Washington, Arizona or Florida pays no California tax on a pre-tax balance built in California. For the committed emigrant, that drops the retirement rate by 9.3 points and makes the traditional door clearly better. But the move has to happen, and California’s residency rules are enforced; a retiree who keeps the Carlsbad condo, the California driver’s license and the summer months on the coast will be treated as a resident.

The Roth as a hedge against staying

Most San Diegans say they will leave and do not. The housing, the climate, the grandchildren and Proposition 13 keep them. A practical way to handle the uncertainty is to see each door as a bet on a future: the traditional door pays off if you leave or if your retirement rate falls; the Roth pays off if you stay in California with a pension or a large balance. A household that splits new contributions, pre-tax 401(k) to the match and beyond, Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) for the rest, holds both bets and gains the ability in retirement to choose which pool to draw from in each year, filling the low federal brackets from the traditional account and taking the rest from the Roth. That flexibility, “tax diversification,” is worth more than the small expected gain from guessing right.

Six features that break the symmetry

The core arithmetic treats the two doors as mirror images. They are not, and the differences almost all favor the Roth for savers who can afford it.

  1. The limit is the same, but the Roth dollars are bigger. $24,500 into a Roth 401(k) is $24,500 of after-tax money; $24,500 into a traditional 401(k) is $24,500 less the future tax, perhaps $16,400 after tax. A saver who maxes the account puts more real money into retirement through the Roth door.
  2. No required minimum distributions from a Roth IRA, or from a Roth 401(k) since 2024, so the account can compound untouched and pass to heirs tax-free. Traditional balances must be drawn from 73 or 75 and are taxed in the heir’s hands within ten years.
  3. Medicare premiums. Part B and D surcharges apply above about $109,000 of modified AGI for a single retiree and $218,000 for a couple, measured two years earlier. Roth withdrawals do not count; traditional withdrawals and RMDs do. A large traditional balance can cost a couple $2,000 to $8,000 a year in surcharges from 65 on.
  4. Social Security taxation. The share of benefits taxed federally rises with other income; Roth withdrawals do not raise it.
  5. Access to contributions. Roth IRA contributions can be withdrawn at any time without tax or penalty.
  6. Future rates are unknown. Today’s federal brackets were made permanent in 2025 legislation, but Congress can change them, and the long-run direction of federal spending and debt points up. The Roth settles the bill at a known rate.

Two features cut the other way. The traditional deduction can pull income under a threshold that unlocks something, the Roth IRA phase-out, a Covered California subsidy, the saver’s credit, or a child tax credit phase-out. And the deduction is worth more to someone at a 45% combined rate than the Roth’s tax-free growth is likely to be, unless they stay in California with a large balance.

The 2026 catch-up rule

SECURE 2.0’s “Rothification” of catch-up contributions takes effect in 2026. A worker aged 50 or over whose Social Security wages from the employer in the prior year exceeded $150,000 (indexed) may make the $8,000 catch-up contribution, or the $11,250 super catch-up at 60 to 63, only as a Roth contribution; if the plan has no Roth option, that worker cannot make a catch-up at all. For a 52-year-old engineer earning $190,000, this means $24,500 can still go in pre-tax and the $8,000 above it must be Roth. The practical steps: confirm the employer plan has added a Roth source, and treat the forced Roth as a feature, since it starts the tax-diversified pool many high earners never built.

Employer match and the Roth 401(k)

Until 2023 the employer match always went into the pre-tax side, even when the employee’s contribution was Roth. Plans may now offer the match as Roth, taxable to the employee in the year received; adoption is still patchy, and a pre-tax match is fine in any case, since it builds the traditional pool that a Roth saver would otherwise lack. What matters is that a Roth 401(k) has no income limit, so a $300,000 earner who is shut out of the Roth IRA can still put the full $24,500 through the Roth door at work.

Conversions: moving between the doors later

The decision is not permanent. A traditional balance can be converted to Roth in any year by paying tax on the amount converted, which turns every low-income year into an opportunity: the year between jobs, the sabbatical, the first years of retirement before Social Security and RMDs, the year of a large deductible loss in a business. A San Diego couple retiring at 62 with $1.5 million in a traditional 401(k) and no pension can convert $80,000 to $100,000 a year for a decade at the 12% and 22% federal rates and California’s lower brackets, reducing RMDs and Medicare surcharges later. The reverse, a Roth to traditional recharacterization of a conversion, has not been allowed since 2018, so conversions should be sized to the bracket and done late in the year when income is known. And a conversion by a resident is California income; the future emigrant converts after the move.

The decision table

Roth or traditional, by situation
Situation Lean Reason
Combined marginal rate under 25% (junior enlisted, residents, early-career, part-time) Roth, entirely Cheapest tax you will ever pay on this money
Public employee or career military with a pension Roth for most The pension fills the low brackets in retirement; withdrawals start at 22% and 9.3%
22% to 24% federal, 9.3% California, no pension, might stay in California Split: pre-tax 401(k) to the match and some beyond; Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) for the rest Tax diversification; the Roth hedges staying, the 401(k) hedges leaving
32% federal and above, planning to retire out of state Traditional 401(k) to the max; backdoor Roth IRA on top Deduction at 41% or more; retirement rate likely 22% to 24% with no state tax
32% and above, staying in California, with a large balance already Mostly Roth going forward RMDs and Medicare surcharges push the retirement rate toward today’s
Income near a threshold (Roth IRA limit, Covered California subsidy, child credit phase-out) Traditional, enough to stay under The deduction unlocks a benefit worth more than the rate difference
Over 50 with prior-year wages above $150,000 Catch-up is Roth by law No choice; make sure the plan offers it
Gap year, early retirement, deployment year Convert traditional to Roth up to the top of the 12% or 22% bracket Lowest rate available

Three San Diego households, worked

Worked examples (illustrative, 7% nominal return)
Household Rates now and later Plan Outcome at retirement
Firefighter, 30, City of San Diego, $105,000, SDCERS pension at 55 31.3% now; pension of $75,000 puts later withdrawals at 22% federal and 9.3% California, 31.3% All Roth: Roth 457(b) $24,500 where offered, Roth IRA $7,500 Roughly equal to traditional on rate, but no RMDs, no Medicare surcharge creep, and a tax-free pool beside the pension
Couple, 38, La Mesa, $230,000 combined, no pensions, undecided on staying 33.3% now; 24% to 31.3% later depending on the move Pre-tax 401(k) $18,000 each; Roth IRA $7,500 each via the backdoor if needed Two pools of about $1.6 million (traditional) and $0.9 million (Roth) at 65, drawn from each year to manage the bracket
Software architect, 47, Carmel Valley, $320,000, intends to retire to Nevada at 60 41.3% now; 24% later, no state tax Traditional 401(k) $24,500; from 50, the $8,000 catch-up is Roth by rule; backdoor Roth $7,500; convert in Nevada from 60 to 70 The deduction saves $10,100 a year today; conversions after the move at 22% to 24% without California tax

A thirty-year projection under three futures

The table runs a single decision, $20,000 a year of salary saved from 35 to 65 at a 7% nominal return, through the two doors under three futures for a San Diego couple at 24% federal and 9.3% California today. The traditional door puts in the full $20,000; the Roth door puts in $13,340 after tax. At 65 the traditional balance is $2,021,000 before tax and the Roth balance is $1,348,000 after tax; the question is what the traditional balance is worth once taxed.

After-tax value at 65 of $20,000 a year for 30 years, by future
Future Retirement rate on withdrawals Traditional, after tax Roth Better door
Stay in San Diego, pension or large balance; withdrawals at 22% and 9.3% 31.3% $1,388,000 $1,348,000 Roughly even; Roth wins once RMDs and Medicare surcharges are counted
Stay in San Diego, modest withdrawals at 12% and 6% 18% $1,657,000 $1,348,000 Traditional by $309,000
Move to Nevada, withdrawals at 22% 22% $1,576,000 $1,348,000 Traditional by $228,000
Stay, with a $90,000 pension and a $2 million balance; withdrawals at 24% and 9.3%, with surcharges About 36% effective $1,293,000 $1,348,000 Roth by $55,000, plus no RMDs

The spread across futures is large, which is the argument for holding both doors rather than guessing. A couple who split evenly ends between $1.32 million and $1.50 million in every future, never the best outcome and never the worst, with the added ability to draw from whichever pool suits each year’s bracket.

The Social Security tax torpedo

Between roughly $25,000 and $60,000 of “provisional income” for a single retiree, and $32,000 to $80,000 for a couple, each extra dollar of traditional withdrawal pulls up to 85 cents of Social Security into taxable income as well, so a 12% federal bracket behaves like a 22% one and a 22% like a 40%. California does not tax Social Security, so the state side is unaffected, but the federal effect is sharp for middle-income retirees drawing $30,000 to $60,000 a year from a traditional account alongside benefits. Roth withdrawals are invisible to the calculation. For a San Diego retiree without a pension who expects a modest portfolio, this effect alone can make the Roth door better even when the headline brackets say otherwise, and it is the reason the “modest withdrawals” row in the table above is less favorable to the traditional door than it looks.

Early retirement and the conversion ladder

A San Diegan who retires at 55 with most savings in a traditional 401(k) faces two obstacles: the 10% penalty before 59½ (waived for withdrawals from the plan of an employer left at 55 or later, but not for IRAs) and a decade of low-income years that would otherwise be wasted. The Roth conversion ladder solves both. Each year from 55, the retiree converts an amount up to the top of the 12% or 22% federal bracket, pays tax at that rate plus California’s, and after five years each converted amount becomes withdrawable without penalty, so that conversions made at 55 fund spending at 60, those at 56 fund 61, and so on, while the first five years are covered by the taxable account and Roth contributions. The ladder also shrinks the traditional balance before RMDs begin at 73 or 75, reducing the surcharges and the heirs’ tax. A couple with $1.5 million in pre-tax accounts at 55 might convert $90,000 a year for 15 years at an average of 20% combined, rather than face RMDs of $100,000 a year at 31% from 75.

The thresholds a traditional contribution can unlock

Benefits that depend on AGI or MAGI, 2026, and how a pre-tax contribution helps
Benefit Threshold Value of staying under
Roth IRA direct contribution $153,000 single; $242,000 joint Avoids the backdoor; convenience only
Covered California premium subsidy (for the self-employed) Subsidy tapers with income; above about 400% of the poverty level, 8.5% of income cap $2,000 to $10,000 a year for a household near the cliff
Child tax credit phase-out $200,000 single; $400,000 joint $50 per $1,000 over, per child
Saver’s credit $40,125 single; $80,250 joint Up to $1,000 per person
Student loan income-driven repayment Payment is a share of discretionary income A $20,000 pre-tax contribution lowers the payment by $1,000 to $2,000 a year
Medicare surcharge (retirees still working) $109,000 single; $218,000 joint $1,000 to $7,000 a year in Part B and D surcharges
Net investment income tax $200,000 single; $250,000 joint 3.8% on investment income above the line

A household within $20,000 of any of these lines should run the numbers with the pre-tax contribution in and out. The Covered California cliff is the most consequential for the self-employed; a San Diego consultant at $125,000 of income with a family of four can lose or gain thousands in subsidies depending on whether $24,500 goes to a solo 401(k) pre-tax or Roth.

RSUs, bonuses and the vesting year

Many San Diego tech and biotech workers have lumpy income: a vesting that lands $80,000 in one year, a signing bonus, a retention award. The marginal rate in that year may be 32% or 35% federal plus 9.3% or 10.3% California, far above the household’s usual rate. That is the year to push contributions to the traditional side, and the following lower year to favor Roth or to convert. The election in the benefits portal can be changed mid-year for the remaining paychecks, and a supplemental wage withholding of 22% federal (37% above $1 million) and 10.23% California on the bonus is not a tax rate, only a prepayment; the real rate appears on the return.

How to change your election

Most employer plans let you set the split between pre-tax and Roth contributions in the benefits portal at any time, by percentage of pay, and apply it to the next payroll. The match follows the plan’s rules regardless. For an IRA, the choice is made account by account: a traditional IRA is deductible only under income limits for workers with a plan at work (see the traditional IRA guide), which is why most San Diego professionals’ IRA money is Roth, direct or through the backdoor. Review the election at each pay change, each move, and each year a pension or Social Security start date comes into view.

Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most

  • Comparing federal rates only and missing that the state’s 9.3% starts at $70,606 of taxable income.
  • Assuming retirement income will be low while holding a CalPERS or military pension that will fill the lower brackets on its own.
  • Betting the whole balance on leaving California, then staying.
  • Never building a Roth pool at all, leaving every retirement dollar exposed to RMDs, Medicare surcharges and the heirs’ ten-year rule.
  • Converting in a high-income working year rather than in a gap year.
  • Not checking that the 401(k) has a Roth source before 2026 catch-up contributions are blocked.
  • Choosing Roth when a traditional deduction would unlock a subsidy or credit worth more than the rate difference.

The one-paragraph version

Find your combined federal and California marginal rate today, estimate the rate your withdrawals will face in retirement counting any pension, Social Security, required distributions and whether you will still live in the state, and choose the door that avoids the higher rate. Under 25% combined, or with a pension coming, go Roth. At 32% federal and above with a credible plan to leave California, go traditional. In the broad middle, where most San Diego professional households live, split, so that both futures are hedged and retirement withdrawals can be managed year by year. Convert in the low-income years, and check that the plan has a Roth source before the 2026 catch-up rule bites.

Read next

Common questions

Federal plus California. A single filer on $98,000 is at 22% federal and 9.3% California, 31.3% combined; a couple on $380,000 is at 32% plus 9.3%, 41.3%. California's 9.3% bracket starts at $70,606 of taxable income for a single filer, far below the federal 24% threshold.

Yes, if the move happens. Federal law prevents California from taxing a non-resident's pension or 401(k) withdrawals, which lowers the retirement rate by 9.3 points or more and favors traditional contributions now. If you might stay, split contributions so the Roth hedges that outcome.

Mostly Roth. The pension is ordinary income that fills the 10% and 12% federal brackets and California's lower brackets by itself, so every traditional withdrawal is taxed at 22% federal and 9.3% state from the first dollar, which is close to your working rate.

Workers aged 50 and over whose prior-year Social Security wages from the employer exceeded $150,000 may make catch-up contributions only as Roth. If the plan has no Roth option, no catch-up is allowed. The regular $24,500 can still be pre-tax.

No. The Roth IRA phases out at $153,000 to $168,000 for single filers and $242,000 to $252,000 for couples, but a Roth 401(k) accepts the full $24,500 at any income, and the backdoor Roth handles the IRA.

Yes. Traditional balances can be converted to Roth in any year by paying tax on the amount converted; the best years are low-income ones. Roth cannot be converted back, and a conversion done while a California resident is California income.

For most San Diego households in the 22% to 24% federal brackets with no pension, a split is sensible: pre-tax 401(k) to the match and part of the rest, Roth IRA and Roth 401(k) for the remainder. It gives two pools to draw from at different rates in retirement.

Sources

  1. IRS, 2026 tax brackets and standard deduction (Rev. Proc. 2025-32)
  2. IRS, 2026 retirement plan contribution limits (Notice 2025-67)
  3. IRS, final regulations on Roth catch-up contributions under SECURE 2.0 section 603
  4. California Franchise Tax Board, 2025 tax rate schedules
  5. 4 U.S.C. 114, limitation on state income taxation of certain pension income
  6. California FTB Publication 1031, guidelines for determining resident status
  7. Medicare, 2026 Part B premiums and income-related adjustments
  8. IRS, required minimum distributions
  9. CalSTRS, pension and Social Security
  10. Social Security Administration, taxation of benefits

#401(k) #Public employees #Retirement #Roth IRA #San Diego #Tax planning

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *