| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Expense ratio, broad US index funds | 0.015% to 0.04% a year (Fidelity, Vanguard, Schwab, iShares) |
| Expense ratio, typical active stock fund | 0.6% to 1.0% a year |
| Share of active US large-cap funds beaten by the S&P 500 over 15 years | About 88% (S&P Dow Jones SPIVA scorecard) |
| Minimum investment | $1 for most ETFs with fractional shares; $0 to $3,000 for mutual funds depending on the firm |
| Federal tax on qualified dividends and long-term gains | 0%, 15% or 20% by income; the 0% band runs to about $49,000 of taxable income single, $99,000 joint, in 2026 |
| California tax on the same | Ordinary rates, 1% to 12.3%, plus 1% above $1 million |
| TSP equivalents | C Fund (S&P 500), S Fund (the rest of the US market), I Fund (international) |
| What an index fund does not do | Protect you from a market fall; the US market dropped about 18% in 2022 and index funds dropped with it |
An index fund is a pooled investment that mechanically holds whatever is in a published list, the index, in the same proportions. A total US market fund owns roughly 3,500 companies weighted by size; an S&P 500 fund owns the largest 500. Nobody at the fund is deciding whether Qualcomm looks promising this quarter. The rules of the index decide, and the fund follows.
That sounds like an absence of skill, and it is. It is also why index funds work. Choosing not to guess removes the cost of guessing: the research staff, the trading, the manager’s fee, and the tax bill that frequent trading generates, which in California is larger than almost anywhere else. For a San Diego investor, whether the money sits in a Qualcomm 401(k), a UC San Diego 403(b), a Navy family’s Thrift Savings Plan or a brokerage account opened last week, the index fund is the default that the alternatives have to beat, and over any period long enough to matter most of them do not.
This guide explains what you own, what it costs, how the California tax rules change the choice between funds, and how to put one to work in each of the account types San Diegans actually have.
What you own in an index fund
Most broad index funds are capitalization-weighted: each company’s share of the fund equals its share of the total market value of all the companies in the index. In a total US market fund in 2026, the ten largest technology and communications companies make up roughly a third of the fund, and the smallest 2,000 companies together make up a few percent. That is not a flaw; it is what the market is. A cap-weighted fund holds the market as investors collectively price it, and when a company grows or shrinks the fund adjusts without trading, because the weight moves with the price.
Three index families cover most needs:
- Total US market (the CRSP US Total Market, Russell 3000 or Dow Jones US Total Market indexes): everything listed in the US, large to small. Vanguard’s VTI, Fidelity’s FSKAX and Schwab’s SWTSX track these.
- S&P 500: the 500 largest US companies, about 80% of the total market’s value. VOO, FXAIX, SWPPX and the TSP’s C Fund track it. Over long periods it and the total market fund move almost identically.
- Total international (FTSE Global All Cap ex US or MSCI ACWI ex USA): developed and emerging markets outside the US. VXUS, FTIHX and the TSP’s I Fund (which covers developed markets and, since 2024, emerging markets and small caps).
Bond index funds work the same way for lending: a total bond market fund such as BND or FXNAX holds thousands of Treasury, agency, mortgage and corporate bonds weighted by amount outstanding.
What it costs, and why that decides more than selection
The expense ratio is the annual fee the fund deducts from its assets, expressed as a percentage. Broad index funds in 2026 charge 0.015% to 0.04%; the typical active stock fund charges 0.6% to 1.0%, and some sold through advisers charge more plus a sales load. The difference compounds against you for as long as you hold the fund.
| Expense ratio | Ending balance | Paid in fees and lost growth |
|---|---|---|
| 0.03% | $1,007,000 | $4,000 |
| 0.50% | $925,000 | $86,000 |
| 1.00% | $851,000 | $160,000 |
| 1.50% | $783,000 | $228,000 |
The second cost is harder to see: turnover. An active fund that replaces half its holdings every year pays trading costs and, in a taxable account, distributes the realized gains to you as taxable income whether or not you sold anything. A total market index fund turns over 2% to 4% a year and distributes almost nothing beyond dividends. In a state that taxes those distributions at up to 12.3% as ordinary income, low turnover is a tax strategy in itself. The expense ratio guide works through the arithmetic in more detail.
The evidence
S&P Dow Jones Indices has published its SPIVA scorecard twice a year since 2002, comparing actively managed funds with their benchmark indexes. The pattern has not changed: over 15 years, roughly 88% of US large-cap active funds trail the S&P 500, and the share rises as the period lengthens, because the fee drag accumulates and because the few managers who beat the market in one period rarely repeat. Morningstar’s active/passive barometer, which also counts funds that closed, finds the same. Survivorship matters: the funds that failed are quietly merged away, so the active funds you can buy today look better than the category actually performed.
None of this says the market is efficient in any philosophical sense, or that nobody can beat it. It says that identifying in advance who will, and paying them, has cost investors more than it earned, consistently, for decades. The index fund is the bet that you cannot identify them either.
How California changes the choice of fund
Three state rules make fund selection matter more in San Diego than in Houston.
Dividends and gains are ordinary income to the state
Federally, qualified dividends and long-term capital gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%. California has no such rate; it taxes both as wages, at 9.3% for most working San Diegans and more above $371,000. A fund that distributes 3% of its value in capital gains every year costs a Californian in the 9.3% bracket about 0.28% of the balance annually in state tax alone, on top of federal. A total market index fund distributes gains rarely, and in a taxable account that difference is worth more than the expense ratio difference.
ETFs distribute even less than index mutual funds
Exchange-traded funds and index mutual funds hold the same stocks, but the ETF structure lets the fund hand out appreciated shares to market makers instead of selling them, so most broad ETFs have not distributed a capital gain in years. In a 401(k) or IRA this is irrelevant; in a taxable brokerage account in California it is a reason to prefer the ETF version. Vanguard’s mutual funds share the ETF’s tax treatment through a patented structure, which expired in 2023 and is now being adopted by other firms. The ETF vs mutual fund guide covers the mechanics.
Which account holds which fund
Because the state cannot tax what happens inside a 401(k), IRA or TSP, put the fund that would otherwise generate the most taxable income there. Bond funds pay interest that California taxes fully, so they belong in retirement accounts, or should be replaced in taxable accounts by Treasury funds, whose interest the state exempts, or California municipal bond funds. International stock funds are best held in taxable accounts, where the foreign tax credit for withholding on their dividends can be claimed; inside an IRA that credit is lost. US stock index funds go anywhere. The three-fund portfolio guide shows the placement in full.
Index funds in each San Diego account
The 401(k) or 403(b) menu
Open the fund list and look for the words “index”, “500”, “total market”, “extended market”, “international index” and “bond index”. Then sort by expense ratio. Large San Diego employers, including Qualcomm, Illumina, Scripps, Sharp and the county, offer index funds at 0.02% to 0.10%; smaller employers’ plans, often run by insurance companies, may offer one S&P 500 fund at 0.4% next to active funds at 1.2%. Take the cheapest broad index option even if the menu is poor, and press the employer, who has a legal duty to monitor plan costs, to add better ones. If the plan is genuinely bad, contribute to the match and put the rest in an IRA.
The TSP
The C Fund is an S&P 500 index fund at about 0.05%; the S Fund covers the US companies not in the S&P 500; the I Fund covers international developed and emerging markets. Four parts C to one part S approximates the total US market. The L funds combine them by target date. For a sailor at Naval Base San Diego with 30 years ahead, the question is only whether to pick the L fund for the retirement year or build the mix by hand; both are index portfolios.
UC San Diego, the county, the city and the school districts
The UC Retirement Savings Program uses Fidelity with a menu built around index funds at institutional pricing. County and city 457(b) plans and district 403(b) plans vary; some 403(b) vendor lists for teachers still carry annuity products with fees above 2%, and the index option, if present, is the one to use.
IRAs and brokerage accounts
At Fidelity, Schwab or Vanguard an index fund costs nothing to buy, has no account fee, and can be purchased in fractional shares with as little as $1. Set an automatic monthly purchase and the account runs itself.
CalSavers
The state’s default investment for workers without an employer plan is a target-date fund built from index funds, which is the right design; the program’s administrative fee is the only drawback, and it matters once the balance is large enough to move to an IRA.
What index funds do not protect you from
An index fund removes manager risk, cost drag and most tax drag. It keeps all of the market’s risk. The US market fell about 18% in 2022, 34% in five weeks in 2020, and 50% from 2007 to 2009, and every index fund fell with it. The protection against that is time, a bond allocation sized to your horizon, and an emergency fund large enough that a layoff never forces a sale. A San Diego biotech employee holding an index fund has diversified away from Illumina’s trial results, but not from the market as a whole; that is the trade.
Two smaller risks are worth naming. Tracking error, the gap between the fund and its index, is a few hundredths of a percent for large funds and can be larger for narrow or leveraged products that use the word “index” loosely. And concentration: the S&P 500’s ten largest companies are about a third of the fund, which is simply what the market looks like, but an investor whose salary and RSUs already depend on one of those companies has more riding on it than the fund shows.
Buying your first index fund, step by step
- Decide the account: 401(k) or TSP for matching money, a Roth or traditional IRA next, a taxable brokerage account for the rest. The San Diego investing guide gives the order.
- Pick one broad fund to start: a total US market fund or an S&P 500 fund. Everything else can wait.
- Check the expense ratio. Under 0.10% is right; under 0.05% is normal.
- Buy it, in dollars rather than shares, and set a recurring purchase for the day after each payday.
- Reinvest dividends automatically inside retirement accounts. In a taxable account, consider taking dividends as cash and using them to rebalance, which avoids buying lots you will later have to track.
- Add an international fund and a bond fund when the balance passes a few thousand dollars, following the three-fund guide.
- Stop looking at it. Check once a quarter at most.
Three San Diego investors and their funds
| Who | Account | Index funds | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nurse at Sharp, 27, first 403(b) | 403(b) with a menu of 20 funds | The S&P 500 index fund at 0.03% and the bond index at 0.04%, 90/10 | The menu’s active funds charge 0.7% to 1.1%; the two index funds cover the whole need |
| Marine sergeant at Miramar, 29 | TSP | L 2060 fund | One decision, index-based, rebalanced for him; Roth TSP while the bracket is low |
| Software engineer in UTC, 36, selling RSUs at vest | Taxable brokerage | Total US market ETF, total international ETF, Treasury money market for cash | ETF structure avoids California tax on distributions; international in taxable for the foreign tax credit; no corporate bond fund in a 9.3% state |
How a fund tracks its index
An index is a list with weights, published by a provider such as CRSP, S&P or FTSE and updated on a schedule. The fund’s job is to hold that list. For the S&P 500 it buys all 500 stocks in proportion, a method called full replication. For a total market index with 3,500 names, the smallest of which trade rarely, most funds hold almost all of them and use statistical sampling for the tail, matching the index’s sector and size profile without owning every $200 million company. The result is a tracking difference of a few hundredths of a percent a year, usually equal to the expense ratio and sometimes less, because the fund earns a little by lending its shares to short sellers.
Index changes happen on announced dates. When a company joins the S&P 500, every S&P 500 fund must buy it that day, and the price often rises in the days before; when a company is delisted or acquired, the funds sell. Total market funds have fewer of these events because a company moving from mid-cap to large-cap does not leave the list. The practical consequence for an owner is nothing: the trading happens inside the fund, and in an ETF it rarely produces a taxable distribution.
Dividends: what you receive and how California treats them
A total US market fund yields about 1.3% in 2026; an international fund about 3%; a bond fund about 4.5%. The fund collects the dividends from its holdings and pays them out quarterly (most stock funds) or monthly (most bond funds). You choose whether to reinvest them automatically or take them as cash.
Federally, most dividends from US stock funds are “qualified” and taxed at the 0%, 15% or 20% long-term rates; bond fund interest and some international dividends are ordinary income. California makes no such distinction and taxes all of it as ordinary income.
| Fund | Yield | Income | Federal tax | California tax | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total US stock (qualified dividends) | 1.3% | $1,300 | $195 | $121 | $316 |
| Total international stock (about 70% qualified, with foreign tax credit) | 3.0% | $3,000 | $520 less credit | $279 | About $700 |
| Total bond market (ordinary interest) | 4.5% | $4,500 | $990 | $419 | $1,409 |
| Intermediate Treasury fund (state-exempt interest) | 4.2% | $4,200 | $924 | $0 | $924 |
The table is the whole argument for asset location in California: the bond fund’s state tax is the largest line, and the Treasury fund removes it. Inside a 401(k) or IRA none of these taxes apply until withdrawal, and inside a Roth, never.
What owning the market has actually felt like
Index investing is often described as boring. The returns are not. Here is what a total US market fund delivered, year by year, through the last decade, with the events a San Diego investor would have been reading about.
| Year | Return | What was happening |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 | +12.7% | Election-year volatility; Brexit |
| 2017 | +21.2% | Calmest year in decades |
| 2018 | −5.2% | A 20% fall in the fourth quarter, recovered within months |
| 2019 | +30.7% | Rate cuts; the biotech index led |
| 2020 | +21.0% | A 34% fall in five weeks in March, then a full recovery by August |
| 2021 | +25.7% | Meme stocks and crypto peaked; index funds did fine without them |
| 2022 | −19.5% | Rates rose; bonds fell too; San Diego biotech layoffs |
| 2023 | +26.0% | Recovery led by a handful of large technology companies |
| 2024 | +23.8% | Continued concentration in the largest names |
$10,000 invested at the start of 2016 was worth roughly $30,000 at the end of 2024 despite two falls of 20% or more and one of 34%. An investor who sold in March 2020 or October 2022 and waited for calm missed most of that. The index fund’s only requirement is to be held through the years in the table that start with a minus sign.
Index funds against the alternatives San Diegans are offered
- Active mutual funds. Covered above: higher cost, higher turnover, higher California tax, lower average return. The exception is a plan whose only cheap option is a decent active fund, where it beats the alternative of not investing.
- Individual stocks. Picking stocks is active management with one analyst and no diversification. The index fund holds every company that will turn out to be the next Nvidia and every one that will turn out to be the next Enron, and the sum has beaten most pickers. A small play account is fine; the retirement account is not the place.
- Rental property. Popular here and genuinely productive, but a single San Diego rental is a leveraged, undiversified, illiquid, management-intensive position in one ZIP code, and most households already have that in their own home. The index fund holds every public real estate company for 0.03%.
- Annuities. Insurance products with 1% to 3% in annual costs and surrender charges, sold to teachers in 403(b) plans and to retirees rolling over a TSP. The guarantees are real and expensive; for most people a bond index fund and Social Security provide the same floor for a tenth of the cost.
- Robo-advisers. Betterment, Wealthfront and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios build index portfolios automatically for 0% to 0.25% on top of fund costs. Reasonable for someone who wants rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting done for them; a three-fund portfolio does the same for 0.25% less.
- High-yield savings. Not an alternative but a complement: the emergency fund belongs there, and the index fund holds what is left over.
Terms you will see on the fund page
| Term | Meaning | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | Annual fee as a share of assets | Under 0.10% for a broad index fund |
| Net asset value (NAV) | Value of the fund’s holdings per share | ETFs trade near it; mutual funds trade at it |
| Tracking difference | Fund return minus index return | Should be close to minus the expense ratio |
| Turnover | Share of holdings replaced each year | Under 10% for a broad index fund |
| Distribution yield | Dividends paid over the last year as a share of price | About 1.3% US, 3% international, 4.5% bonds in 2026 |
| Capital gains distribution | Realized gains paid to holders, taxable in a brokerage account | Zero or near zero for broad ETFs |
| Share class | Different fee versions of the same fund (Investor, Admiral, Institutional, R6) | The cheapest one your account allows |
| Securities lending | Lending holdings to short sellers for a fee | Offsets part of the expense ratio; disclosed in the annual report |
Objections, answered
- “Index funds will fall when everyone owns them.” Index funds own about half of US fund assets; prices are still set by the trading of the other half and of institutions. If active management became more profitable, more money would move to it. It has not.
- “I’d rather own companies I understand.” You can, with a small share of the portfolio. Qualcomm and Illumina staff in San Diego already own more of one company than any adviser would recommend; the index fund is the counterweight.
- “The S&P 500 is just big tech now.” It is about a third big tech, which is what the US economy’s market value looks like. A total market fund adds small companies; an international fund adds everything else; neither escapes the fact that the largest companies are large.
- “My adviser’s funds have beaten the index.” Over what period, after what fees, and compared with which index? The SPIVA data say the honest answer is usually a short period, before fees, against the wrong benchmark.
Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most
- Holding a bond index fund in a taxable account when a Treasury fund would pay the same before tax and more after California tax.
- Buying the 401(k)’s S&P 500 fund at 0.45% without noticing the same index is available at 0.02% in an IRA.
- Owning five index funds that hold the same stocks: a total market fund, an S&P 500 fund, a large-cap growth fund and a technology fund are mostly one position.
- Selling in the fall. The index fund is designed to be held through it; selling converts a temporary loss into a permanent one and, in California, a taxable event.
- Forgetting the RSU basis when selling employer shares to fund the index purchase; the 1099-B often shows $0 and the tax is paid twice.
Leave a Reply