Money, planning and life on the Coast

Investing

Target-Date Funds for San Diego Savers: The TSP L Funds, 401(k) Defaults, CalSavers and the One Account to Keep Them Out Of

The fund most San Diegans already own without choosing it. Picked well, it is a complete plan at 0.05% to 0.12%; picked by default in the wrong series, it is a 0.9% fee on autopilot.

What to take away

  • A target-date fund holds US stocks, international stocks and bonds, rebalances automatically, and shifts toward bonds as the target year approaches; most keep shifting for seven to ten years after it.
  • Index-based series (Vanguard Target Retirement 0.08%, Fidelity Freedom Index 0.12%, Schwab Target Index 0.08%, TSP L funds 0.05%) cost a sixth of the active series often set as plan defaults.
  • Hold target-date funds in a 401(k), 403(b), 457(b), TSP, IRA or CalSavers; never in a taxable brokerage account in California, where their rebalancing distributions are taxed at ordinary rates.
  • Pick the year by the fall you can hold through, using the glide path, not by your birth date; a pension or military retirement justifies a later year.
  • Hold nothing else in the same account; a target-date fund plus an S&P 500 fund is an undocumented, riskier fund.
  • Exchanging an active series for an index series inside a plan is free and tax-free, and is the single most valuable five-minute change in many San Diego 403(b) accounts.
At a glance: target-date funds for San Diego savers, 2026
Item Figure
What it is One fund holding US stocks, international stocks and bonds, with the mix shifting toward bonds as the target year approaches
Cost, index-based series Vanguard Target Retirement 0.08%; Fidelity Freedom Index 0.12%; Schwab Target Index 0.08%; TSP L funds about 0.05%
Cost, actively managed series 0.45% to 0.90% (Fidelity Freedom, American Funds, T. Rowe Price, many 401(k) defaults)
Where it belongs 401(k), 403(b), 457(b), TSP, IRA, HSA, CalSavers
Where it does not belong A taxable brokerage account in California, because of distributions
Stock share at 30 years out About 90%
Stock share at the target year About 50%, continuing to fall for 7 to 10 years in most series
How to pick the year By the risk you can hold through, not by your birth date

A target-date fund is the three-fund portfolio with the decisions made for you. It holds a US stock index fund, an international stock index fund and a bond index fund, rebalances them automatically, and moves the mix toward bonds as the year in its name approaches. For the Navy family at 32nd Street, the Sharp nurse enrolled in a 403(b) during orientation, and the restaurant worker enrolled in CalSavers without asking for it, it is the fund they already own, usually without having chosen it.

That makes it worth understanding, because the right target-date fund is one of the best investments available and the wrong one is a 0.9% fee on autopilot. This guide covers how the funds work, which series are worth owning, how to pick the year, and the one account where a Californian should never hold one. Figures are for 2026.

How the glide path works

Every target-date fund follows a glide path, a schedule of stock-bond mixes by years to the target. Thirty years out, most series hold about 90% stocks. At the target year they hold about 50%, and most keep reducing for another seven to ten years after it, to around 30% stocks, on the theory that a retiree who reaches 65 will be invested for another 25 years. Funds that stop adjusting at the target date are called “to” funds; the more common ones that keep going are “through” funds. The difference matters at the moment of retirement: a 2030 “through” fund will still be 55% stocks in 2030 and will fall to 30% by 2037.

A representative glide path (Vanguard Target Retirement series, approximate)
Years to target US stocks International stocks Bonds
30 or more 54% 36% 10%
20 52% 34% 14%
10 45% 30% 25%
0 (the target year) 30% 20% 50%
7 after 18% 12% 70%

The TSP’s L funds follow a similar path and roll into the L Income fund, at about 25% stocks, when they reach their year.

Index series and active series: the difference that matters

The word “target-date” says nothing about cost. Two families of funds share the name:

  • Index-based series built from index funds: Vanguard Target Retirement (0.08%), Fidelity Freedom Index (0.12%), Schwab Target Index (0.08%), State Street Target Retirement (0.09%), BlackRock LifePath Index (0.09% in many plans), and the TSP’s L funds (about 0.05%).
  • Actively managed series built from active funds: Fidelity Freedom (not “Index”, about 0.75%), American Funds Target Date (0.60% to 0.70% in the cheapest share class, more in others), T. Rowe Price Retirement (0.50% to 0.65%), John Hancock, Principal and most of the series that insurers put into small-employer plans at 0.6% to 0.9%.

The two kinds hold the same asset classes on similar glide paths. The difference is 0.5 to 0.8 percentage points a year, which over a career is the difference in the fee table in the expense ratio guide: roughly a sixth of the ending balance. The most common target-date mistake in San Diego 401(k) and 403(b) plans is holding “Fidelity Freedom 2055” when “Fidelity Freedom Index 2055” is three lines down the same menu at a sixth of the cost.

Where a target-date fund belongs

The 401(k), 403(b), 457(b) and TSP

Federal rules let employers default new employees into a target-date fund (a “qualified default investment alternative”), and most large San Diego employers do. The L fund is the TSP’s default for new service members. In these accounts a target-date fund is close to ideal: one holding, automatic rebalancing, no tax consequences from the rebalancing, and institutional pricing if the series is an index one.

IRAs and HSAs

Equally suitable. A Roth IRA holding a single Vanguard or Schwab target-date fund is a complete retirement plan at 0.08%. In an HSA, remember that California taxes the account’s gains each year; a target-date fund’s internal rebalancing can create small distributions, so some Californians prefer a single stock index fund there and let the HSA be the aggressive account.

CalSavers

The state program’s default is a target-date fund built from index funds, which is the right design. The program fee adds roughly 0.3% to 0.4% on top, acceptable at small balances and worth leaving once the account is large enough to move to a brokerage IRA holding the same kind of fund at 0.08%.

Not the taxable brokerage account

The 2021 lesson. Target-date funds rebalance internally by selling, and those sales produce capital gains distributions in a taxable account. In December 2021, Vanguard’s Target Retirement funds distributed gains of up to 15% of their value, after large retirement plans moved to a cheaper institutional version and the funds sold holdings to pay them out. Investors who held the funds in taxable accounts owed federal tax and, in California, state tax at ordinary rates on money they never withdrew. Hold target-date funds only in tax-advantaged accounts. In a taxable account, build the three-fund portfolio from ETFs instead.

Picking the year

The year in the fund’s name is a label, not a rule. The 2060 fund is 90% stocks and the 2035 fund is about 65%; if you were born in 1994 but would sell at the first 30% fall, the 2045 fund is the honest choice. Conversely, a 45-year-old Navy chief with a pension on the way can hold the 2060 fund, because the pension is the bond allocation the fund does not see. Pick by the mix you can hold through the worst year, using the glide path table, and ignore the retirement date arithmetic.

Two refinements. If your plan offers both a target-date series and index funds, and you have other accounts, consider whether the target-date fund’s bond share belongs in this account at all; the three-fund guide explains why, in California, bonds belong in pre-tax accounts and international stocks in taxable ones, which a single fund cannot do. And once a target-date fund is held, hold nothing else in that account; adding an S&P 500 fund “for growth” alongside a 2055 fund just makes an undocumented 2065 fund.

Inside a target-date fund

Open the holdings of Vanguard’s Target Retirement 2050 fund and there are four lines: Total Stock Market Index, Total International Stock Index, Total Bond Market Index and Total International Bond Index, at roughly 54%, 36%, 7% and 3%. The 2030 fund holds the same four plus a short-term inflation-protected bond fund that grows as the target approaches, to protect spending power in the first years of retirement. Fidelity’s Freedom Index series adds a long-term Treasury fund and a small commodity allocation. The TSP’s L 2050 is simply C, S, I, F and G in a published mix. In every case the building blocks are the broad index funds a do-it-yourself investor would choose, which is why the index-based series track the three-fund portfolio so closely.

Glide paths compared

The biggest difference between series is not cost but how much stock they hold at the target year and how quickly they reduce it afterward.

Stock allocation by series (approximate, 2026)
Series 30 years out At the target year Final mix Years after target to reach final
Vanguard Target Retirement 90% 50% 30% 7
Fidelity Freedom Index 90% 55% 19% About 18
T. Rowe Price Retirement 98% 55% 30% 30
BlackRock LifePath Index 99% 40% 40% 0 (“to” path)
TSP L funds 99% About 25% (L Income) 25% 0 at rollover to L Income

Two consequences follow. A 2030 fund from one series may hold 15 points more stock than another’s 2030 fund, so comparing by year across providers is misleading. And the “through” series assume you will keep the fund for decades after retiring, which is reasonable for a 65-year-old but not for someone retiring at 58 on a CalPERS pension who wants to draw from the fund immediately; that person may want the series’ earlier year, or the three-fund portfolio with a chosen mix.

How they behaved in 2008, 2020 and 2022

The 2008 crisis is the reason the industry rebuilt its glide paths. Several 2010 target-date funds, meant for people two years from retirement, fell 30% to 40% because they held 60% or more in stocks; a Senate hearing followed, and most series became more conservative near the target. In 2020 a typical 2060 fund fell about 32% from February to March and recovered by August; a 2025 fund fell about 20%. In 2022, when both stocks and bonds fell, the diversification between them provided less help than usual: a 2060 fund lost about 18% and a 2025 fund about 15%, with the inflation-protected bonds in the near-retirement funds the only part that held up.

The honest summary is that a target-date fund’s year tells you how far it will fall, approximately, and that the funds did what their glide paths said they would. Investors who sold a 2060 fund in March 2020 missed a 60% rise over the following 18 months; the fund itself required nothing but patience.

Target-date funds in retirement

A fund that reaches its year does not stop. Vanguard’s 2025 fund will merge into Target Retirement Income, at 30% stocks, around 2032; the TSP’s L 2025 rolled into L Income in 2025. Drawing from one is simple: sell shares for the amount you need, and the fund’s internal mix means the sale is automatically proportional, with no decision about which fund to tap. The cost of that simplicity is the one described in the three-fund guide: a retiree with pre-tax, Roth and taxable accounts cannot place bonds in the pre-tax account and stocks in the Roth when a single fund holds everything, and in a taxable account the fund’s distributions are taxed by California every year. Many retirees keep the target-date fund in the 401(k) or IRA and build the taxable account separately, which is a reasonable middle path.

Age-based portfolios in 529 plans

The same design appears in college savings plans under a different name. California’s ScholarShare offers “enrollment year” portfolios that shift from stocks to bonds and cash as the child approaches college, exactly like a target-date fund with a shorter horizon and a steeper path, ending near 100% bonds and cash in the enrollment year. The index-based versions cost about 0.1% to 0.2%; the actively managed versions about 0.5%. A child born in 2026 belongs in the 2044 enrollment portfolio; the 529 guide covers the choice.

Questions to ask about your plan’s default

  1. Which series is it, and is the word “Index” in the name?
  2. What is the expense ratio of the specific share class in my plan?
  3. What is the stock allocation at the target year, and how many years after does it keep falling?
  4. Is there an index-based series on the same menu with the same target year?
  5. Did the plan put me in the fund for my 65th birthday, and is that the mix I would choose?
  6. Am I holding anything else in the account alongside it?

Series worth owning, and what to check

Target-date series available to San Diego savers, 2026
Series Cost Where you find it Note
TSP L funds About 0.05% Thrift Savings Plan Cheapest available; L 2070 to L Income; rolls to L Income at the target year
Vanguard Target Retirement 0.08% Vanguard IRAs, many 401(k)s Index-based; “through” glide path; the 2021 distribution was in taxable accounts only
Fidelity Freedom Index 0.12% Fidelity IRAs, UC Retirement Savings Program, many 401(k)s Not the same as “Fidelity Freedom” (active, about 0.75%)
Schwab Target Index 0.08% Schwab IRAs, some 401(k)s Index-based
State Street Target Retirement 0.09% Many 401(k)s as a collective trust Index-based
BlackRock LifePath Index About 0.09% Large 401(k)s, CalSavers (underlying) Index-based; “to” glide path, more conservative at the target
American Funds, T. Rowe Price, John Hancock, Principal 0.50% to 0.90% Small-employer 401(k)s Active; check the menu for an index alternative

To check any series: find the expense ratio, confirm whether the underlying funds are index funds, look at the stock share at the target year (anywhere from 30% to 55% across the industry), and see whether the plan’s share class is the cheapest one available.

Two target-date funds in one household

A Navy spouse with a TSP L fund and a civilian spouse with a Fidelity Freedom Index fund in a Scripps 403(b) hold two funds that each think they are the whole portfolio. That is fine as long as the two years roughly agree and nothing else is held alongside them; the household’s overall mix is simply the weighted average. The problem arises when one spouse also holds a brokerage account of individual stocks, or when the two funds are 2035 and 2060 because the employers defaulted each person to their own retirement year while the couple plans to retire together. Pick one retirement year for the household, set both funds to it, and treat any other account as an adjustment, not a separate plan.

What the 2021 distribution cost, in dollars

The warning above deserves a number. A San Diego couple holding $300,000 of Vanguard Target Retirement 2040 in a taxable account received a December 2021 capital gains distribution of about 12% of the fund’s value, roughly $36,000, mostly long-term. Federal tax at 15% was $5,400; California tax at 9.3% was $3,350; total $8,750, on a year in which they sold nothing and the fund’s price fell by the same $36,000 on the ex-date, leaving them exactly where they started minus the tax. The same $300,000 in three ETFs would have distributed about $4,000 of dividends and no gains, for a combined tax near $1,000. The gap, $7,700, is the cost of the convenience in one unusual year; in an ordinary year the target-date fund in a taxable account still distributes some gains from rebalancing, typically 1% to 3%, which is $700 to $2,100 of tax a year on that balance.

Changing the year

The target year is not a commitment. Inside a retirement account, moving from the 2050 fund to the 2040 fund is a free exchange, and there are moments when it is the right move:

  • A pension start date becomes clear. A CalPERS or military pension covering essentials argues for a later year, because the fund no longer has to be the safe part of the plan.
  • An inheritance or a house sale. A large taxable account built as a three-fund portfolio may take over the bond allocation, letting the retirement account hold a later, more aggressive year.
  • A lived experience of loss. Someone who discovered in 2022 that a 20% fall was more than they could watch has learned something the glide path did not know, and an earlier year is the honest response.
  • Marriage or divorce. The household’s horizon and risk capacity change; the year should follow.

What should not change the year is a market move. Shifting to an earlier fund after a fall locks in the loss at the moment the fund’s own rebalancing is buying stocks cheaply.

Rolling a target-date 401(k) into an IRA

When you leave an employer, the plan’s target-date fund may not exist outside the plan, particularly the collective trust versions that large San Diego plans use, so a rollover arrives as cash. Buy the IRA’s equivalent the day it lands: Vanguard Target Retirement, Fidelity Freedom Index or Schwab Target Index for the same year, at 0.08% to 0.12%. The share class trap runs the other way too: a plan may hold an institutional class of a target-date fund at 0.06% that the retail IRA version prices at 0.12%, in which case leaving the money in the old plan is cheaper, provided the plan allows former employees to stay and charges no account fee. The TSP allows it and is almost always the cheapest option; most private plans allow balances over $7,000 to remain.

Three questions people ask

“Is a target-date fund too conservative for me?” If you are under 40, the fund for your retirement year is 85% to 90% stocks, which is as aggressive as most advisers would go. If you want more, pick a later year rather than adding other funds. Beyond 90% there is nowhere to go except leverage, which is not a plan.

“Why did my 2060 fund fall as much as the S&P 500?” Because at 90% stocks it is nearly the S&P 500 plus international, which fell by a similar amount. The bond share only becomes a cushion as the target approaches. The fund did exactly what the glide path said.

“Should I have one target-date fund or the three funds in my 401(k) and a different arrangement in my IRA?” Either works, but the simplest robust setup is a target-date index fund in every retirement account and a three-ETF portfolio in the taxable account, which keeps the taxable account free of distributions and the retirement accounts free of effort. The three-fund guide explains when the fully customized version is worth the hour a year.

Moving from a target-date fund to the three funds, and back

There is no need to move. A target-date index fund held for a career is a complete, well-executed plan, and many households should never do anything else. Reasons to switch to the three funds are specific: a taxable account that needs ETFs, a desire to place bonds and international in the tax-efficient accounts, a pension that justifies a mix the glide path cannot express, or a plan whose only target-date series is an expensive one. Inside a retirement account, switching is a free exchange with no tax; the reverse is just as free when a household decides it would rather not rebalance.

Target-date funds against the neighbors on the menu

Three other “do it for me” options often sit beside the target-date series in a San Diego plan. A balanced fund holds a fixed 60/40 mix forever, which suits someone who wants a constant allocation and will change funds themselves later; it never becomes more conservative on its own. A managed account from the record-keeper allocates the plan’s funds for you for 0.3% to 0.6% a year, which is a target-date fund with a fee and a questionnaire. A stable value fund is a cash-like option, not a portfolio. Against all three the index target-date series is cheaper, more diversified or both, and it is the right default for a participant who does not want to think about it, which is most participants, and most of the time the correct choice for the ones who do.

Three San Diego savers and their target-date choices

Worked examples (illustrative)
Who Account Choice Why
Seaman at Naval Base San Diego, 20, first enlistment TSP L 2070, Roth TSP, 5% of basic pay One decision, cheapest fund in the market, full government match; pension on the way argues for the most aggressive fund
Respiratory therapist at Scripps, 38, defaulted into an active 2050 fund at 0.72% 403(b) Exchanged into the plan’s index 2050 series at 0.10% Same glide path, 0.62 points cheaper, no tax on the exchange; on $120,000 that is about $740 a year
Couple in Oceanside, 44 and 46, with a taxable account holding Vanguard Target Retirement 2045 Taxable brokerage Stopped adding; new money to VTI, VXUS and VGIT; the old fund kept until a low-income year or a gift to a child Selling would realize gains taxed by California at 9.3%; the fund’s own distributions are the ongoing cost

Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most

  • Holding the active series when the index series is on the same menu. Look for the word “Index” in the fund name.
  • Holding a target-date fund in a taxable account and paying California tax on rebalancing you never saw.
  • Owning two target-date years at once, or a target-date fund plus other funds, which undoes the glide path.
  • Picking the year by birth date rather than by the fall you can hold through.
  • Leaving the TSP in the G Fund instead of the L fund, which costs a 20-year-old most of the growth in the plan.
  • Assuming “target-date” means low risk. A 2060 fund fell about 18% in 2022, as it should have.

Read next

Common questions

Yes. A 2060 fund is about 90% stocks and fell roughly 18% in 2022; a 2035 fund is about 65% stocks. The year is a label for the mix, so choose the mix you can hold through a bad year.

Freedom Index is built from index funds at about 0.12%; Freedom is actively managed at about 0.75%. They follow similar glide paths. Many San Diego hospital and university plans offer both, and the index version is the one to hold.

The L fund for the year you expect to start withdrawing, or a later one if a military pension will cover your essentials. L funds cost about 0.05% and roll into L Income at their target year. Any L fund beats leaving the balance in the G Fund for decades.

You can, but in California you should not. The fund's internal rebalancing distributes capital gains that the state taxes as ordinary income. In December 2021 some target-date funds distributed up to 15% of their value. Use ETFs in taxable accounts.

No. The target-date fund already holds the S&P 500 inside it. Adding more makes the mix more aggressive in an undocumented way; if you want more stocks, choose a later target year instead.

Yes, it is an index-based target-date fund. The program fee of roughly 0.3% to 0.4% is the only drawback, and once the balance reaches a few thousand dollars a brokerage IRA holding a similar fund at 0.08% is cheaper.

Only for a specific reason: a taxable account, a wish to place bonds and international stocks in tax-efficient accounts, a pension that changes the right mix, or an expensive target-date series with no index alternative. Otherwise a target-date index fund held for a career is a complete plan.

Sources

  1. Thrift Savings Plan, lifecycle funds
  2. Vanguard, Target Retirement Funds glide path and expense ratios
  3. Fidelity, Freedom Index Funds
  4. Schwab, Target Index Funds
  5. Morningstar, Target-Date Strategy Landscape report
  6. US Department of Labor, qualified default investment alternatives
  7. Wall Street Journal and Morningstar coverage of the 2021 Vanguard target-date distributions
  8. CalSavers, investment options
  9. California Franchise Tax Board, capital gains distributions on Form 540
  10. UC Retirement Savings Program, fund menu

#Index funds & ETFs #Military families #Public employees #Retirement accounts #San Diego #Starting out

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *