| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Who needs it | Single filers above $168,000 and joint filers above $252,000 of modified AGI, who cannot contribute to a Roth IRA directly |
| Amount per person per year | $7,500; $8,600 at 50 or older |
| The two steps | Non-deductible contribution to a traditional IRA, then conversion of that IRA to Roth |
| Tax due on the conversion | Only on any earnings between contribution and conversion, usually a few dollars, provided no other pre-tax IRA money exists |
| The trap | The pro-rata rule: any pre-tax balance in any traditional, SEP or SIMPLE IRA on December 31 makes the conversion partly taxable |
| The form | Form 8606, filed with the return for both the contribution and the conversion |
| Mega backdoor, where the 401(k) allows it | After-tax 401(k) contributions up to the $72,000 overall limit, converted to Roth |
| California treatment | Conforms to federal; no separate state consequence |
A couple in Carmel Valley earning $290,000 cannot put a dollar directly into a Roth IRA; the income limit closed the door at $252,000. They can, however, put $7,500 each into a traditional IRA with no deduction and convert it to a Roth the following week, paying tax on nothing, because no deduction was taken. The result is identical to a direct Roth contribution. Congress built the income limit for contributions and removed the income limit for conversions in 2010, and has since confirmed in committee reports that using the two together is permitted. That is the backdoor Roth. It takes fifteen minutes a year and, for a San Diego professional household above the limits, is the only way to add $15,000 a year to the one account California can never tax.
This guide gives the steps, the pro-rata rule that trips most people, the fix for it, the reporting, the mega backdoor through a 401(k), the timing questions, and the situations where the backdoor is the wrong tool. It assumes the Roth IRA guide.
Who should use it
Anyone over the Roth IRA income limit who has already captured the employer match and is saving beyond the 401(k), or who prefers Roth money for the reasons in the Roth versus traditional guide. In San Diego that describes a large group: two-income couples at Qualcomm, Illumina, the Navy’s civilian labs and the hospital systems; physicians; senior engineers; and attorneys. It also describes households near the limit who would rather not calculate modified AGI in December; the backdoor works at any income, so a couple at $240,000 can use it and stop worrying about the phase-out.
The steps
- Open a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA at the same brokerage, if you do not have them. Fidelity, Schwab and Vanguard all handle the process online.
- Contribute $7,500 to the traditional IRA as a non-deductible contribution for the tax year. The brokerage does not ask whether it is deductible; that is decided on your return. Leave it in the settlement fund; do not invest it yet.
- Convert the traditional IRA to the Roth IRA. Each brokerage has a “convert to Roth” button or form; choose to convert the entire balance and decline tax withholding. Many people wait a few days for the contribution to settle; waiting weeks or months is not required and only creates taxable earnings.
- Invest the money in the Roth in the fund you would have chosen for a direct contribution.
- File Form 8606 with the year’s return, reporting the non-deductible contribution (Part I) and the conversion (Part II). The form tracks your “basis,” the after-tax dollars, so that the conversion is not taxed twice.
- Repeat each year, ideally in January, and for each spouse separately.
Done this way, with no other IRA money, the taxable amount on the conversion is the earnings in the few days between steps 2 and 3, typically under $10.
The pro-rata rule
The IRS treats all of a person’s traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs as one account for conversion purposes. If any of them hold pre-tax money, a conversion is taxed in proportion to the pre-tax share of the total, measured on December 31 of the conversion year, regardless of which account the converted dollars came from. The 401(k) is not an IRA and is not counted; a spouse’s IRAs are not counted.
| Other pre-tax IRA balance on Dec 31 | Total IRA balance | After-tax share | Taxable portion of the $7,500 conversion | Tax at 33.3% combined |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $0 | $7,500 | 100% | $0 | $0 |
| $20,000 | $27,500 | 27% | $5,455 | $1,817 |
| $150,000 | $157,500 | 4.8% | $7,143 | $2,379 |
| $600,000 | $607,500 | 1.2% | $7,407 | $2,467 |
The tax is not a penalty; the untaxed basis remains in the traditional IRA and comes out tax-free later. But it defeats the purpose, because the point was to move $7,500 of after-tax money into a Roth, not to pay $2,400 to move mostly pre-tax money. The usual sources of the problem: a rollover IRA from an old employer, a SEP IRA from a stretch of self-employment, or a deductible IRA from years ago.
The fix: empty the pre-tax IRAs first
Three ways to clear the decks before December 31 of the conversion year:
- Roll the pre-tax IRA into the current employer’s 401(k). Most large San Diego employers’ plans accept “roll-ins,” and so do the TSP and most 403(b) plans. Only pre-tax money can go; the plan will ask you to certify that. The money then sits in the 401(k), outside the pro-rata calculation, and the backdoor is clean. This is the standard fix for anyone with a rollover IRA.
- Open a solo 401(k), if you have any self-employment income, and roll the IRA into it. The self-employed consultant with a SEP IRA should do this and stop using the SEP, since a solo 401(k) allows larger contributions anyway and does not block the backdoor.
- Convert the whole pre-tax IRA to Roth and pay the tax, which is sensible only if the balance is small or the year’s income is low.
Once the pre-tax IRAs are at zero on December 31, the pro-rata share is 100% after-tax and every future conversion is tax-free. The order matters: the roll-in can happen any time in the year, even after the conversion, as long as the balance is zero on December 31.
Reporting: Form 8606 and the 1099-R
The brokerage will send a Form 5498 showing the traditional IRA contribution and a Form 1099-R showing the conversion as a distribution, with the full $7,500 in box 1 and, usually, box 2b “taxable amount not determined” checked. Tax software routinely gets this wrong unless told about the non-deductible basis, and a preparer who is not asked will tax the whole conversion. The return should show the $7,500 non-deductible contribution on Form 8606 Part I, the conversion on Part II, and a taxable amount of a few dollars or zero on Form 1040. Keep every year’s Form 8606 permanently; the cumulative basis it tracks is the proof, decades later, that the money was already taxed. A missing 8606 can be filed late, with a $50 penalty that the IRS often waives.
Timing within the year
The contribution is for a tax year and can be made until the following April 15; the conversion is a calendar-year event reported in the year it happens. A contribution for 2026 made in March 2027 and converted the same week shows up on the 2026 Form 8606 (the contribution) and the 2027 Form 8606 (the conversion), which is correct but confuses software. The clean pattern is to contribute and convert in January of the tax year itself. Contributing early also gives the money eleven more months in the market.
The step-transaction question, settled
For years, advisers worried that the IRS could treat a contribution followed immediately by a conversion as a single disguised Roth contribution over the income limit. The conference report to the 2017 tax law stated in four places that the contribution-then-conversion sequence is allowed, and the IRS has said publicly that it is. No waiting period is required, and the earnings during any wait are simply taxable.
The mega backdoor Roth
The 401(k) has a second, larger backdoor. The $24,500 employee limit applies to pre-tax and Roth deferrals, but the overall limit on everything that goes into the account, employee deferrals plus employer contributions plus “after-tax” contributions, is $72,000 in 2026 ($80,000 with the catch-up). If the plan allows after-tax contributions and either in-plan Roth conversions or in-service withdrawals, an employee can fill the gap between the deferrals, the match and $72,000 with after-tax money and convert it to Roth, immediately or periodically. An engineer deferring $24,500 with a $10,000 match has $37,500 of after-tax room; converted, that is $37,500 a year into Roth on top of the $7,500 IRA backdoor.
Not every plan allows it. Qualcomm’s and several other large San Diego employers’ plans do; many mid-sized plans do not, and plans with poor participation among lower-paid workers may limit after-tax contributions for high earners through nondiscrimination testing. The questions to ask the plan administrator: does the plan accept after-tax (not Roth) contributions, does it allow in-plan Roth conversion of them or in-service distribution to a Roth IRA, and how often. Earnings on after-tax money between contribution and conversion are taxable when converted, so automatic or frequent conversion is better than annual. A solo 401(k) can be written to allow the same thing for a self-employed San Diegan, which is a further reason to prefer it to a SEP.
When the backdoor is the wrong tool
- You are under the income limit. Contribute directly; the backdoor adds paperwork for no benefit.
- You have a large pre-tax IRA you cannot move. If no 401(k) accepts roll-ins and there is no self-employment income for a solo 401(k), the pro-rata tax usually makes the backdoor not worth doing; a Roth 401(k) at work and the taxable account are the alternatives.
- You have not captured the 401(k) match or are carrying credit card debt. The order of operations puts those first.
- You are in a very high bracket and plan to leave California. The backdoor is still worth $7,500 a year, but the larger decision is the traditional 401(k), and the backdoor should not distract from it.
Spouses and the spousal backdoor
Each spouse has a separate $7,500 limit and separate IRAs, and the pro-rata rule is applied per person. A non-working spouse can make a spousal contribution on the working spouse’s income and convert it; a working spouse with a rollover IRA cannot contaminate the other spouse’s clean backdoor. Couples where one spouse has a pre-tax IRA problem and the other does not should run the backdoor for the clean spouse while the other’s IRA is being rolled in.
Three San Diego households
| Household | Situation | Steps | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two engineers, 34 and 36, University City, $310,000 combined, no IRAs | Over the limit; both 401(k)s maxed; Qualcomm-style plan allows after-tax | Each contributes $7,500 to a traditional IRA in January and converts the next week; one spouse adds $30,000 of after-tax 401(k) with automatic in-plan conversion | $45,000 a year into Roth accounts; Form 8606 for each; tax on conversions under $20 |
| Physician, 41, Scripps, $420,000, with a $180,000 rollover IRA from residency | Pro-rata would tax 96% of a backdoor conversion | Rolls the $180,000 into the Scripps 403(b) in March; backdoor in April | Clean backdoor from 2026 on; $8,600 a year once 50 |
| Self-employed consultant, 45, Encinitas, $260,000 net, SEP IRA of $95,000 | Over the limit; SEP blocks the backdoor | Opens a solo 401(k) with after-tax and Roth provisions, rolls the SEP into it, stops SEP contributions; backdoor IRA plus mega backdoor through the solo plan | Up to $7,500 plus tens of thousands of after-tax solo 401(k) money converted to Roth each year |
Reading the forms the brokerage sends
Three documents arrive and each needs to be matched to the return. Form 5498, issued in May, reports the traditional IRA contribution in box 1 and, for the Roth, the conversion amount in box 3; it is informational and does not get attached. Form 1099-R, issued in January, reports the conversion as a distribution from the traditional IRA: box 1 shows the gross amount, box 2a often shows the same figure, box 2b has “taxable amount not determined” checked, and box 7 carries distribution code 2 (under 59½, exception applies) or 7 (over 59½). The software’s interview will ask whether the distribution was converted to a Roth; answer yes, and separately enter the non-deductible contribution so that Form 8606 line 1 shows $7,500 of basis. The resulting Form 1040 should show the conversion on line 4a (IRA distributions) and only the earnings, usually under $10, on line 4b (taxable amount). If line 4b shows $7,500, the basis was not entered and the return is wrong. California’s Schedule CA mirrors the federal figures and needs no separate entry.
The steps at each brokerage
The mechanics differ slightly. At Fidelity, the contribution goes into the traditional IRA’s core position, and after it settles (usually the next business day for an electronic transfer) the “Transfer” page offers the Roth IRA as a destination with a conversion prompt; the whole balance can be moved, with withholding declined. At Schwab, the “Convert to Roth” form is under account services, and the same settlement wait applies. At Vanguard, the traditional IRA holds the money in the settlement fund, and the “Convert to Roth IRA” link under the account menu moves it in one step. In all three, the transfer within the same brokerage is instantaneous once initiated, and the Roth’s cash can be invested the same day. A contribution made by check or from an external bank may take several business days to clear before a conversion is allowed; a transfer from the brokerage’s own taxable account is usually faster.
A mega backdoor year, worked
| Source | Amount | Tax treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Employee pre-tax deferral | $24,500 | Deducted now; taxed on withdrawal |
| Employer match (50% of the first 6% of pay) | $6,300 | Pre-tax |
| After-tax contribution (the gap to the overall limit) | $41,200 | After tax; earnings taxable until converted |
| Total into the plan | $72,000 | The section 415(c) limit |
| In-plan Roth conversion of the after-tax source, automatic each payroll | $41,200 plus a few dollars of earnings | Taxable only on the earnings |
| Backdoor Roth IRA | $7,500 | Taxable on earnings only |
| Roth money added this year | $48,700 | Tax-free forever |
The after-tax contribution has to come out of take-home pay, which for this engineer is a large share of it; most people fill the after-tax space only after the Roth IRA, the HSA and a taxable account with at least a modest balance, and the order of operations puts the mega backdoor near the end. Where the budget allows it, though, nothing else in the tax code produces $48,700 of Roth space in one year.
If the traditional IRA already has earnings
A contribution left uninvested for a few days earns a few cents; one left in a money market fund for six months earns $150 and one invested in a stock fund for a year might earn $700 or lose $500. The earnings are taxed as ordinary income on conversion, which is a minor nuisance, not a reason to delay further. A loss is worse: a $7,500 contribution that has fallen to $7,000 converts $7,000, and the $500 of unused basis stays on Form 8606 to offset future conversions, which is why the money should sit in cash between the two steps.
Doing it for last year
The contribution for 2026 can be made until April 15, 2027, which allows a saver who did nothing in 2026 to make the 2026 contribution in early 2027, convert it, and then make the 2027 contribution and convert that too, all in the same month. The 2026 Form 8606 reports the 2026 contribution; the 2027 Form 8606, filed a year later, reports both the 2027 contribution and the two conversions (both happened in 2027). The pro-rata rule is tested on December 31, 2027 for both conversions. It works; it just produces two years of forms that must be read together, and tax software often needs the prior-year basis entered manually.
Spouses and the pro-rata rule, worked
A La Jolla physician has a $220,000 rollover IRA; her spouse, a teacher, has only a 403(b). Each wants a $7,500 backdoor. The spouse’s conversion is clean: the pro-rata calculation considers only his IRAs, which hold nothing but the new contribution. The physician’s conversion would be 97% taxable; she rolls the $220,000 into her hospital’s 403(b), which accepts pre-tax roll-ins, and then converts. If the hospital’s plan did not accept roll-ins, her alternatives would be to convert the whole $220,000 (paying tax on it at 35% and 9.3%, which is rarely wise) or to skip the backdoor and use the Roth 403(b) at work instead, while her spouse continues his clean backdoor each year.
The backdoor and the 2026 catch-up rule
Workers over 50 whose prior-year wages exceeded $150,000 must make 401(k) catch-up contributions as Roth from 2026, which means most people doing the backdoor are also now making $8,000 of Roth catch-up at work. The IRA catch-up of $1,100 is unaffected and follows the backdoor route. For a 55-year-old at $200,000, the year’s Roth additions are $8,000 (catch-up at work) plus $8,600 (backdoor IRA), and the pre-tax 401(k) deferral is still $24,500.
What the backdoor is worth over a career
| Years of contributions | Total contributed | Value at the end | Tax saved versus a taxable account at 15% capital gains plus 9.3% California, paid on gains |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $150,000 | $222,000 | About $17,000 |
| 20 | $300,000 | $658,000 | About $87,000 |
| 30 | $450,000 | $1,516,000 | About $259,000 |
Fifteen minutes a year, over a career, is worth a quarter of a million dollars of tax to a San Diego couple who stay in the state, and the Roth also removes the balance from RMDs and from the heirs’ tax. There is no other fifteen minutes in personal finance with that return.
Timing around a job change
A job change in the middle of a year creates two hazards. The old 401(k), if rolled into an IRA out of habit on the way out, lands in the pro-rata calculation for that December 31 and taxes a conversion already made in January. The fix is to roll the old plan into the new employer’s plan, or to leave it where it is until the new plan accepts roll-ins; a rollover IRA opened in March and emptied into the new 401(k) by December is harmless, since only the December 31 balance counts. The second hazard runs the other way: a worker who leaves a job with no new plan, for self-employment or a gap year, loses the roll-in destination; a solo 401(k) opened before December 31, funded with even a small contribution from self-employment income, restores it. In both cases the January conversion was correct and does not need to be undone; the year-end balance is what has to be managed.
The one-paragraph version
If your income is above the Roth IRA limit, contribute $7,500 to a traditional IRA as non-deductible in January, convert it to Roth a few days later, invest it, and file Form 8606 with the return; the tax is a few dollars. Before doing so, make sure every traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA you own will be empty on December 31, by rolling pre-tax balances into a 401(k), 403(b), TSP or solo 401(k). Check that the return shows a near-zero taxable amount on the conversion. Repeat for the spouse, and ask the 401(k) administrator whether after-tax contributions and in-plan conversion are available for the larger version.
A checklist for January
- Confirm all traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances are zero, or arrange the roll-in.
- Contribute $7,500 ($8,600 at 50) to the traditional IRA as non-deductible.
- After the deposit settles, convert the full balance to the Roth IRA, no withholding.
- Invest in the Roth.
- Repeat for the spouse.
- Ask the 401(k) administrator about after-tax contributions and in-plan conversion.
- In April, check that the return includes Form 8606 for each spouse with the right basis and that the conversion’s taxable amount is near zero.
Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most
- Converting with a rollover IRA still open, and paying tax on most of the conversion.
- Omitting Form 8606, so the conversion is taxed in full now and the basis is lost.
- Leaving the money in the traditional IRA for months, creating taxable earnings and sometimes forgetting the conversion entirely.
- Taking a deduction for the contribution by mistake, which turns the conversion fully taxable.
- Using a SEP IRA when self-employed instead of a solo 401(k), which blocks the backdoor every year.
- Doing it without checking the match and debt first.
- Assuming the mega backdoor is available without reading the plan document.
Leave a Reply