| Where | Typical annual cost |
|---|---|
| Broad index ETFs and index mutual funds | 0.015% to 0.08% |
| Thrift Savings Plan funds | About 0.05% |
| Target-date index funds in a large 401(k) | 0.08% to 0.15% |
| Target-date funds in a small-employer 401(k) | 0.40% to 0.90% |
| CalSavers | About 0.3% to 0.5% including administration |
| Actively managed stock funds | 0.50% to 1.20% |
| 403(b) annuity products sold to teachers | 1.5% to 2.5%, plus surrender charges |
| Adviser managing the account | 0.75% to 1.25% of assets on top of fund costs |
| What 1% a year costs on $500 a month over 30 years | About $100,000 of a $590,000 ending balance |
Of everything that decides how much money you have at retirement, the fee is the only one you control completely and the only one that compounds against you with certainty. Returns are uncertain. Taxes depend on Congress and Sacramento. The expense ratio is printed on the page, charged every day, and never gives anything back. A San Diego nurse paying 0.9% in a hospital 403(b) and a UC San Diego administrator paying 0.03% in the university’s plan can save the same amount for the same years in the same market, and the administrator will retire with about a quarter more.
This guide explains what the expense ratio is and is not, what the other costs are that do not appear in it, what each kind of San Diego account actually charges, and how to audit your own accounts in half an hour. Figures are for 2026.
What the expense ratio is
The expense ratio is the percentage of a fund’s assets deducted each year to pay for running it: management, administration, custody, legal, marketing. It is taken out of the fund’s holdings a little every day, so it never appears as a line on your statement; it simply makes the fund’s return lower than its index’s return by that amount. A fund with a 0.80% expense ratio tracking an index that returned 8% delivers 7.2%.
Because it is a percentage of assets rather than of profit, it is charged in bad years as well as good ones. In 2022, when the US market fell about 18%, an active fund charging 1% delivered about minus 19%, and the manager was paid in full.
Why a fraction of a percent is a fortune
The arithmetic is the whole argument.
| Annual cost | Ending balance | Lost to cost | Share of the gross result lost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.03% | $604,000 | $3,000 | 0.5% |
| 0.25% | $580,000 | $27,000 | 4% |
| 0.75% | $531,000 | $76,000 | 13% |
| 1.00% | $508,000 | $99,000 | 16% |
| 2.00% | $424,000 | $183,000 | 30% |
At 2%, which is what some 403(b) annuity products and adviser-plus-active-fund arrangements charge, nearly a third of the growth is gone. The cost is highest in the final years, when the balance is largest: a 1% fee on $500,000 is $5,000 a year, every year, in retirement, for a service that for an index fund consists of tracking a list.
Costs that are not in the expense ratio
The expense ratio is the visible fee. Several others sit beside it:
- Sales loads. A front-end load takes up to 5.75% of each purchase; a back-end load takes a percentage if you sell within a few years. Index funds have none. Any fund sold at a bank branch or by an insurance agent should be checked for one.
- 12b-1 fees. Marketing and distribution charges of up to 1% that are inside the expense ratio but worth noticing, because they pay the person who sold you the fund.
- Plan administration fees. A 401(k) or 403(b) also charges for record-keeping, either as a flat annual amount per participant ($30 to $100) or as a percentage of assets (0.1% to 0.5%). The annual fee disclosure, required by federal rule 404(a)(5), lists them.
- Transaction fees. Some brokerages charge $20 to $50 to buy a rival firm’s mutual funds; ETFs and the brokerage’s own funds are usually free.
- Bid-ask spreads. For ETFs, a cent or two per share on large funds; more on small ones.
- Turnover and tax. A fund that trades heavily pays trading costs and, in a taxable account, distributes gains that California taxes as ordinary income. Morningstar’s “tax cost ratio” estimates it; for active funds it often exceeds the expense ratio.
- Advisory fees. An adviser who manages your account charges 0.75% to 1.25% of assets on top of the funds’ own costs. The combined figure is what matters.
- Annuity charges. Mortality and expense charges, administrative fees, sub-account fees and surrender charges that can total 2% to 3% a year in the variable annuities still sold inside some school district 403(b) plans.
What each San Diego account charges
The TSP
The Thrift Savings Plan’s funds cost about 0.05% a year, among the lowest in the world, with no load, no transaction fee and no adviser. For the roughly 115,000 active-duty members in the county, the TSP is the cheapest account they will ever hold, which is one reason not to roll it to an IRA after separation unless the IRA is at a firm charging the same.
Large-employer 401(k) plans
Qualcomm, Illumina, Scripps, Sharp, the county and the city negotiate institutional pricing; index funds in these plans cost 0.02% to 0.10% and administration is often paid by the employer. The problem in large plans is not cost but choice: the menu may bury the index funds among thirty active options, and the default target-date fund may be an active series at 0.6% rather than an index series at 0.1%.
Small-employer 401(k) plans
A 15-person engineering firm in Sorrento Valley or a restaurant group in North Park often has a plan sold by a payroll company or an insurer, with total costs of 1% to 2% once fund expenses, record-keeping and the adviser’s share are added. Contribute to the match, then weigh whether the rest belongs in an IRA at 0.03%. The employer has a fiduciary duty to monitor costs, and pointing this out, with the fee disclosure in hand, has moved more than one small plan to a cheaper provider.
UC San Diego, the county, the city and CalPERS Savings Plus
The UC Retirement Savings Program’s Fidelity index funds and the state’s Savings Plus plan are priced like large 401(k)s, at a few hundredths of a percent. County and city 457(b) menus vary; some include a stable value fund and index funds at 0.1% and others carry 0.5% options. The plan’s fee disclosure is on the provider’s site.
School district 403(b) plans
This is where San Diego’s costs are worst. Many districts, including some of the largest in the county, let teachers choose from a vendor list that mixes low-cost providers (Fidelity, Vanguard, CalSTRS Pension2) with insurance companies selling variable and fixed annuities inside the 403(b) at 1.5% to 2.5% a year plus surrender charges of up to 7% for leaving early. The products are sold in the staff room by agents who are paid commission. A teacher with $150,000 in such an annuity pays about $3,000 a year for what a Pension2 index fund would provide for $100. Check the district’s vendor list for the low-cost names, and if you are already in an annuity, find the surrender schedule and the date it ends.
CalSavers
The state program charges a combined fee of roughly 0.3% to 0.5% depending on the fund, reasonable for an automatic Roth IRA with no employer involvement, and higher than a brokerage IRA by a factor of ten. Once the balance passes a few thousand dollars, a rollover to a Fidelity or Schwab IRA cuts the cost to nearly zero.
Brokerage accounts and IRAs
At Fidelity, Schwab and Vanguard, broad index funds cost 0.015% to 0.08%, there is no account fee and no commission on ETFs or the firm’s own funds. This is the floor, and every other account should be measured against it.
Reading a fund page and a fee disclosure
Two numbers appear on most fund pages: the gross expense ratio and the net expense ratio. The net figure is what you pay today; the gross figure is what you would pay if a fee waiver expired, and waivers do expire. A fund showing 0.05% net and 0.35% gross is a 0.35% fund with a temporary discount. Index funds from the large firms have no waiver gap.
The same fund usually comes in several share classes with different fees for the same holdings: Vanguard’s Investor and Admiral classes, Fidelity’s Investor and Institutional, and in 401(k) plans the R-share classes (R1 through R6), where R6 is cheapest and R1 or R2 carries revenue-sharing fees that pay the plan’s record-keeper. If your 401(k) holds “American Funds Growth Fund R3” at 0.98%, the same fund exists as R6 at 0.30%, and the difference is paying for the plan’s administration in a way the fee disclosure should explain.
The annual 404(a)(5) disclosure that plans must send has three parts: a table of each fund’s expense ratio and its performance against a benchmark; a list of administrative fees charged to accounts (record-keeping, legal, audit) in dollars or as a percentage; and a list of individual fees (loan processing, distributions). The quarterly statement then shows the actual dollars deducted. Those two documents, read once, tell you everything on this page about your own plan.
The school district 403(b) problem, in detail
California school districts administer 403(b) plans differently from private employers. Rather than choosing one provider, most districts maintain a list of approved vendors and let each teacher pick, and the list is often dominated by insurance companies that have cultivated access to campuses for decades. The state built 403bcompare.com, a public registry where every vendor must disclose fees, specifically because the products were so hard to compare.
Three questions sort the list. Is the product a mutual fund account or an annuity? Annuities add a mortality and expense charge of 1% or more on top of the underlying funds. Is there a surrender charge, and for how long? Seven years declining from 7% is typical, which means leaving early costs thousands. What are the total annual costs of the cheapest diversified option? Under 0.25% is available from CalSTRS Pension2, Fidelity, Vanguard and a few others on most district lists; over 1.5% is common from the rest.
A teacher already in an annuity has two options: a 1035 exchange to a lower-cost annuity, which preserves the tax treatment but may restart surrender charges, or waiting out the schedule and transferring to a mutual fund 403(b) at the end. The surrender math usually favors waiting if fewer than three years remain and leaving immediately if the charge is under 3%, because the 1.5% annual cost saved exceeds the charge within two years.
Robo-advisers and managed accounts
Automated advisers such as Betterment and Wealthfront build an index portfolio, rebalance it and harvest tax losses for about 0.25% a year on top of fund costs of around 0.1%. Schwab Intelligent Portfolios charges no advisory fee but holds a cash allocation of 6% to 10% that earns less than the market, which is the fee in another form. Inside 401(k) plans, “managed account” services from the record-keeper charge 0.3% to 0.6% to allocate among the plan’s own funds, which a target-date fund in the same plan does for 0.1%. None of these are bad products; each is a convenience priced at a few tenths of a percent, and the question is whether the convenience is worth the dollar amount it produces at your balance.
A full-career comparison
The earlier table used a flat $500 a month. Real contributions rise with income. The table below assumes a San Diego household contributing 10% of a salary that starts at $60,000 at 25 and grows 3% a year to about $195,000 at 65, at a 7% gross return.
| Total annual cost | Balance at 65 | Difference from 0.05% | Annual cost in the final year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05% (TSP, index funds) | $2,090,000 | $0 | $1,000 |
| 0.25% (robo-adviser plus index funds) | $1,980,000 | $110,000 | $4,900 |
| 0.75% (active target-date fund) | $1,720,000 | $370,000 | $12,900 |
| 1.25% (adviser plus index funds) | $1,510,000 | $580,000 | $18,900 |
| 2.00% (adviser plus active funds, or a 403(b) annuity) | $1,240,000 | $850,000 | $24,800 |
The final-year column is the one to show a spouse who thinks a 1% fee is small. At 2%, the household pays about $25,000 in the year it retires, for a service an index fund performs for $1,000.
Talking to your employer about plan costs
Employers who sponsor a 401(k) or 403(b) are fiduciaries under federal law, which means they must act in participants’ interest and monitor costs, and they have been sued, successfully, for leaving expensive share classes in plans when cheaper ones were available. Most small San Diego employers have never read their own fee disclosure. A short, specific note works better than a complaint: “Our plan’s S&P 500 fund costs 0.45%; the same index is available at 0.02%. Could we ask the provider to add the cheaper share class or an index series?” Attach the 404(a)(5) notice. Many record-keepers will add funds on request because the alternative is losing the plan to a competitor. If nothing changes, the fallback is the match-then-IRA approach above.
Advisers: what 1% buys and what it does not
An adviser charging 1% of assets on a $600,000 portfolio takes $6,000 a year, roughly $500 a month, forever, rising as the portfolio grows. For that the client receives portfolio management that an index fund does by default, plus, from good advisers, planning, tax coordination and behavioral discipline that can be worth more than the fee in some years. The question is whether the same planning can be bought by the hour or by the project from a fee-only fiduciary adviser, which in San Diego costs $200 to $400 an hour or $2,000 to $5,000 for a full plan, with no ongoing percentage. For most households with index portfolios, it can. The adviser percentage is justified mainly for people who would otherwise not stay invested, which is a real category and worth being honest about.
Auditing your own accounts in thirty minutes
- List every account: 401(k), 403(b), 457(b), TSP, IRAs, brokerage, HSA, CalSavers, any old employer plan.
- For each fund, find the expense ratio on the fund’s own page or the plan’s fee disclosure. Write it down.
- Add the plan’s administrative fee if it is charged to you, from the annual 404(a)(5) notice.
- Add any advisory fee as a percentage.
- Multiply each account’s balance by its total percentage to get the dollar cost per year. The total is what you pay to invest.
- Compare with the floor: the same balance at 0.05%. The difference is the annual cost of the current arrangement.
- Act on the largest gaps first: swap active funds for index funds within the same plan (no tax, no cost), move old employer plans to a cheaper IRA, and question any annuity.
Three San Diego savers
| Who | Before | After | Annual saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fourth-grade teacher in Chula Vista, $150,000 in a 403(b) variable annuity | 2.1% total cost: $3,150 a year | Moved to CalSTRS Pension2 index funds at 0.1% once the surrender period ended: $150 a year | $3,000 |
| Marketing manager at a 20-person agency in Little Italy, $90,000 in a small-plan 401(k) | 1.4% total: $1,260 a year | Contributes to the match only; new money to a Schwab Roth IRA at 0.03%; old balance rolled to the IRA at the next job change | About $1,100, growing |
| Retired Navy captain in Coronado, $900,000 with an adviser at 1% in active funds averaging 0.7% | 1.7% total: $15,300 a year | Three-fund index portfolio at 0.04%; a fee-only planner for $3,000 every other year | About $13,500 |
A full household audit, in dollars
Here is the audit above applied to a two-income Carmel Valley household, before and after, so that the dollar amounts are visible.
| Account | Balance | Before: holding and cost | Annual cost | After | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Her 401(k), biotech employer | $310,000 | Active target-date fund, 0.62%, plus 0.08% plan fee | $2,170 | Index target-date series, 0.09%, plus plan fee | $530 |
| His 403(b), hospital | $180,000 | Four active funds averaging 0.85%, plus 0.15% plan fee | $1,800 | Plan’s three index funds, 0.05%, plus plan fee | $360 |
| Old 401(k) from a 12-person firm | $45,000 | R2 share class target-date fund, 1.35% | $610 | Rolled to a Schwab IRA, three index ETFs, 0.04% | $18 |
| Two Roth IRAs | $95,000 | Adviser-managed, 1.0% plus active funds 0.7% | $1,620 | Self-managed, two index funds, 0.05% | $48 |
| Joint brokerage | $120,000 | Same adviser, 1.0% plus 0.7% | $2,040 | Three index ETFs, 0.04% | $48 |
| Total | $750,000 | $8,240 | Fee-only planner every other year, $3,000 | About $2,500 |
The household recovered about $5,700 a year, which, invested, is roughly $250,000 over the 25 years to retirement. The changes took two afternoons and one phone call to the hospital’s HR department.
Negotiating with an adviser you want to keep
Some households value their adviser and would rather lower the cost than leave. Three things are negotiable. The percentage itself: most firms have breakpoints, often 1% below $1 million falling to 0.75% or 0.5% above, and will apply a lower tier to a client who asks. The funds inside: an adviser who holds index funds for you charges the same percentage but the total drops by half a point. And the structure: many advisers will quote a flat annual retainer, $3,000 to $8,000, instead of a percentage, which for a portfolio above $500,000 is cheaper and does not rise as the account grows. Ask for all three in writing. An adviser who will not discuss cost has told you what the relationship is.
The cost inside a guarantee
Stable value funds, fixed annuities and the guaranteed-income riders on variable annuities promise that a balance will not fall or that an income will not stop. The promise is real; its price is in the yield. A stable value fund paying 3.2% when a Treasury fund pays 4.2% is charging a point a year for smoothing. An indexed annuity that credits a share of the market’s rise with a cap of 8% and a floor of 0% gives up every year above 8% and all dividends, which over a decade has cost holders roughly half the market’s return. For a retiree who would otherwise sell in a fall, a modest guarantee can be worth its price; for most San Diego households with a pension or Social Security as the floor, a bond index fund and a cash buffer provide the stability at a tenth of the cost.
How the fees got this low
In 2010 a typical index fund cost 0.18% and a typical active fund 1.0%. Competition among Vanguard, Fidelity, Schwab and BlackRock drove the broad index products to 0.03% by 2018 and to zero at Fidelity, while active fees fell only slowly. The result is the widest gap in history between the cheapest and the typical: a San Diegan can hold the whole US market for less than the cost of a cup of coffee per $10,000 a year, or can pay a hundred times that for a fund that will probably trail it. The price war has not reached school district 403(b) lists, small-plan 401(k)s or the products sold outside the bases, which is why those three places are where the audit finds the money.
When a higher fee is worth paying
Rarely, and in specific cases: a target-date fund at 0.15% that keeps someone invested who would otherwise tinker; a stable value fund at 0.4% inside a 401(k) that pays more than a bond fund with no price risk; a California municipal bond fund at 0.1% that saves more than that in state tax; a fee-only planner for a year with a job change, an inheritance or a retirement date. The test is always the same: what does the extra cost buy, measured in dollars, against the index alternative?
This week
Three things fit in one evening. Log into the workplace plan, find the fund list, and switch to the index options or the index target-date series; the exchange is free and takes effect at the next close. Find the most recent fee notice in the plan’s documents and read the administrative fee line. And if any account is with an adviser, write down the total percentage you pay, adviser plus funds, and the dollar amount it produced last year. The number alone usually decides what happens next.
Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most
- Buying a 403(b) annuity from the agent in the staff room. It is the most expensive retirement product sold in the county.
- Leaving an old 401(k) with a small employer at 1.4% when a rollover to an IRA at 0.03% is a form away.
- Confusing the adviser’s 1% with the total. Add the funds’ expense ratios; the total is what compounds.
- Rolling the TSP to an IRA with higher-cost funds after leaving the Navy.
- Paying a load on a fund that has a no-load equivalent tracking the same index.
- Ignoring the 404(a)(5) notice. It arrives once a year and is the only document that lists every cost.
Leave a Reply