| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| High-deductible plan, minimum deductible | $1,700 self-only, $3,400 family |
| High-deductible plan, maximum out-of-pocket | $8,500 self-only, $17,000 family |
| Any ACA plan, maximum out-of-pocket | $10,600 self-only, $21,200 family |
| HSA contribution limit | $4,400 self-only, $8,750 family, plus $1,000 at 55 |
| Federal tax treatment of the HSA | Deductible going in, untaxed growing, untaxed coming out for medical costs |
| California tax treatment of the HSA | No deduction; earnings taxed every year |
| Typical premium gap, employer HDHP vs PPO, family | $150 to $300 a month less for the HDHP |
| Typical employer HSA deposit | $500 to $2,000 a year, when offered |
| San Diego’s dominant HMO | Kaiser Permanente; Sharp and Scripps also run HMO networks |
Open enrollment in San Diego’s large employers runs through October and November, and the form usually offers three kinds of plan: a high-deductible health plan with a health savings account, a PPO, and one or more HMOs, often including Kaiser. The HDHP has the lowest premium and the scariest deductible; the PPO has the highest premium and the most freedom; the HMO sits in between with a network that may or may not include the hospital you would want. Most people pick by premium and regret it in February, or pick by fear and overpay for a decade.
This guide compares the three on the only number that matters, what a year actually costs you, works the break-even for three San Diego households, and covers the California rule that makes the HSA worth less here than in Texas, though still usually worth having. Figures are for 2026.
The three designs, and what each is for
High-deductible health plan with an HSA
A plan with a deductible of at least $1,700 for one person or $3,400 for a family in 2026, and an out-of-pocket maximum no higher than $8,500 or $17,000. Preventive care is covered before the deductible; almost everything else, including most prescriptions, is paid in full by you until the deductible is met. In exchange the premium is lower and you may contribute to a health savings account, up to $4,400 for self-only coverage or $8,750 for a family, plus $1,000 at 55, with the federal tax treatment nothing else in the tax code matches.
PPO
A preferred provider organization lets you see any doctor without a referral, at a lower cost in-network and a higher one out of it. Deductibles are lower, copays apply to office visits and prescriptions from day one, and the premium is the highest of the three. In San Diego the PPO’s practical value is access to all four hospital systems, Sharp, Scripps, UC San Diego Health and Kaiser (for emergencies), plus Rady Children’s and the North County hospitals, without asking permission.
HMO
A health maintenance organization limits you to its network and routes specialists through a primary care doctor. Kaiser is the largest in the county and is its own closed system; Sharp Health Plan and the Scripps networks offered through Blue Shield, Health Net and others are the alternatives. Premiums are usually between the HDHP’s and the PPO’s, copays are predictable, and the out-of-network coverage is nil except in emergencies. For a household whose doctors are all in one system, an HMO is often the cheapest plan for the same care.
The only comparison that matters: a year’s cost
Three figures decide it: the annual premium (your share), the deductible, and the out-of-pocket maximum, plus any money the employer deposits in an HSA. Compute two scenarios for each plan: a typical year, using last year’s actual claims, and a worst year, which is the premium plus the out-of-pocket maximum minus any employer HSA deposit.
| HDHP with HSA | PPO | Kaiser HMO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Employee premium, monthly | $310 | $560 | $420 |
| Deductible | $3,500 | $1,000 | $0 |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | $7,000 | $6,000 | $6,000 |
| Employer HSA deposit | $1,500 | $0 | $0 |
| Office visit | Full cost until deductible, then 20% | $30 copay | $25 copay |
| Worst year (premium + maximum − deposit) | $9,220 | $12,720 | $11,040 |
| Light year ($800 of care) | $3,020 | $7,000 | $5,200 |
| Typical year ($4,500 of care, including a specialist and two prescriptions) | $6,420 | $8,400 | $6,600 |
In this menu the HDHP wins in every scenario, because the premium gap ($3,000 a year) plus the employer deposit ($1,500) exceed the difference in maximums. That is common but not universal; the arithmetic flips when the employer deposits nothing, the premium gap is small, or the HDHP’s maximum is at the $17,000 ceiling. Run it with your own plan’s numbers before deciding.
Where the HDHP wins, and where it loses
The HDHP wins when the premium saving plus the employer deposit covers most of the deductible, when the household can pay the deductible from savings in a bad month, and when the HSA will actually be funded. It wins by the widest margin for healthy households that use little care and for high earners who value the federal deduction.
The PPO or HMO wins when care is predictable and heavy: a pregnancy planned for next year, a chronic condition with monthly specialists and expensive drugs, a child in therapy. In those years the PPO’s copays and lower deductible, or the HMO’s $0 deductible, can beat the HDHP even after the premium gap. It also wins for households that would put off needed care to avoid paying the deductible, which the research finds HDHP enrollees do.
The HMO wins for a household already inside Kaiser or Sharp, with no reason to leave, that wants the lowest premium with predictable copays and no deductible; and it loses the moment a child needs Rady Children’s or a parent needs a specialist at UC San Diego that the network does not include.
The HSA: the best account in the tax code, with a California asterisk
Federally, HSA contributions are deducted from income, the account’s investment growth is untaxed, and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are untaxed, which no 401(k) or Roth matches. Unused balances roll over forever, the account is yours when you change jobs, and after 65 withdrawals for any purpose are taxed like a traditional IRA with no penalty. Contributions through payroll also avoid Social Security and Medicare tax. For a San Diego household in the 22% federal bracket, a full $8,750 family contribution saves about $1,925 of federal income tax and $670 of payroll tax.
California does not recognize HSAs. The state adds your contributions back to income on Form 540 and taxes the account’s interest, dividends and capital gains every year, as if it were a brokerage account. For the same household in the 9.3% state bracket, the full family contribution costs about $814 of state tax that a Texan would not pay, and an invested HSA produces a small annual state bill on its earnings. The federal benefit, about $2,600 in the example, still outweighs it. The honest arithmetic is a net saving of roughly $1,800 a year rather than $2,600, plus the paperwork of tracking the account’s earnings for the state return.
Running the HSA well
- Fund it to the limit if you can, after the 401(k) match and before the IRA, as the investing guide orders it.
- Invest the balance above a cash buffer of one deductible in a single broad index fund, to keep California’s annual tax on earnings small and the reporting simple.
- Pay current medical costs from cash if the budget allows, keep the receipts, and let the HSA compound; the receipts can be reimbursed tax-free decades later.
- The last-month rule: if you are covered by an HDHP on 1 December you may contribute the full year’s limit, provided you stay covered through the following year.
- Stop contributing six months before Medicare Part A, which is backdated six months at enrollment after 65; contributions during that window are penalized.
- Medi-Cal, TRICARE and a spouse’s general-purpose FSA all disqualify HSA contributions, as does any non-HDHP coverage. A military spouse covered by TRICARE cannot contribute even if the employer offers an HDHP.
The FSA, for everyone else
A PPO or HMO enrollee can use a health flexible spending account instead: up to $3,400 in 2026, pre-tax federally and for California (which does recognize FSAs), but use-it-or-lose-it beyond a small carryover of about $680, and not portable between jobs. A limited-purpose FSA for dental and vision can sit alongside an HSA. The dependent-care FSA, up to $7,500, is separate and available with any plan; for a San Diego family paying $1,700 a month for childcare it is worth about $2,500 a year and is the benefit most often left unused.
The San Diego network question, again
The plan design matters less than whether the plan reaches the hospital you would want. Before choosing, write down your doctors, the pharmacy, and the one hospital you would want to be taken to (Sharp Memorial or Grossmont, Scripps Mercy or La Jolla, UC San Diego Hillcrest or Jacobs, Kaiser Zion, Rady Children’s, Palomar or Tri-City in North County) and check each against every plan’s own directory. An HDHP and a PPO from the same carrier usually share a network; a Kaiser HMO shares nothing. A Chula Vista family whose pediatrician is at Rady should not enroll in a plan that treats Rady as out of network, whatever the premium.
Three San Diego households, compared
| Household | Expected care this year | Best plan | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Couple in their thirties, Normal Heights, no children, both healthy | $1,000 to $2,000: physicals, one urgent care visit, a dental emergency | HDHP, HSA funded to $8,750 | Light year cost about $3,500 against $7,500 on the PPO; federal HSA saving about $2,600, state cost about $800; $3,500 cash buffer held for the deductible |
| Family in Chula Vista, second child due in April | $25,000 or more: prenatal care, delivery at Sharp Mary Birch, newborn care | PPO or Sharp HMO for this year | Both will hit the maximum; the PPO’s $12,720 worst year beats the HDHP’s $9,220 only if… it does not, so the HDHP still wins on worst-year arithmetic, but the family chooses the HMO’s $0 deductible for cash-flow reasons in the delivery month and switches back next enrollment |
| Teacher in La Mesa, 52, type 1 diabetes, insulin and quarterly endocrinology | $9,000 to $12,000 every year | PPO with the district’s low-deductible option | Predictable heavy use; insulin copays under the PPO beat full price under the HDHP until the deductible; UC San Diego endocrinology is in the PPO network |
The Chula Vista row shows something worth saying plainly: the HDHP often wins the arithmetic even in a baby year, because the maximums are close and the premium gap is large, but a plan with a $0 deductible can still be the right choice for a family that would otherwise face a $3,500 bill in the month the baby arrives. Cash flow is a legitimate reason, as long as it is the reason and not the premium.
Switching plans
You can change plans at open enrollment or within 30 days of a qualifying event: marriage, birth, adoption, a spouse’s job loss, a move that changes the available plans. Moving from an HDHP to a PPO mid-year does not forfeit the HSA; the balance stays, you simply stop contributing. Moving from a PPO to an HDHP mid-year prorates the contribution limit unless the last-month rule applies. Deductibles reset on the plan year, which for most San Diego employers is January; if a large procedure can be scheduled, the end of a year in which the deductible is already met is the cheapest time.
Covered California and the self-employed
Bronze plans on Covered California are HDHP-qualified in most cases and the cheapest way for a self-employed San Diegan to combine a low premium with an HSA, whose contributions are deductible against self-employment income federally. Silver plans with cost-sharing reductions, for incomes under 250% of the poverty level, are not HSA-eligible but can be the better deal after the reductions. The San Diego health insurance guide covers the marketplace in full, including the 2026 premium changes.
An HDHP year, month by month
The annual comparison hides the timing problem. On a PPO, costs arrive as copays spread across the year. On an HDHP, the deductible is usually met in a lump, early, by whichever family member gets sick first, and the household needs the cash on hand in February rather than averaged over twelve months. The table follows a family of four on an HDHP with a $3,400 family deductible, a $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum and a $2,000 employer HSA contribution, through a year in which a child breaks an arm in March and a parent has a minor surgery in September.
| Month | Event | Billed to family | Deductible met | HSA balance after (family adds $560 a month) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January | Employer deposits $2,000; preventive visits, free | $0 | $0 | $2,560 |
| March | Emergency room, X-ray, cast: $4,200 allowed | $3,400 deductible plus 20% of the rest, $560 | $3,400 | $0 (short by $280, paid from savings) |
| April to August | Follow-ups and a prescription: $900 allowed | $180 (20% coinsurance) | Met | $2,620 by August |
| September | Outpatient surgery: $11,000 allowed | 20% up to the $7,000 cap: $2,860 brings total to the cap | Met | $320 |
| October to December | Everything covered at 100% | $0 | Cap reached | $2,000 by year end |
The family paid the full $7,000 maximum, $5,000 of it from the HSA, in a bad year. The same family on the employer’s PPO would have paid about $4,400 in extra premium plus roughly $3,500 in copays and coinsurance for the same events, $7,900 in total, with no HSA balance at the end. The HDHP still won, narrowly, and only because the employer’s contribution and the premium saving were large; the point of the table is the March row, where a family without $3,700 in cash would have put the deductible on a credit card.
The California asterisk, in numbers
California is one of two states that does not recognize the HSA. Contributions made through payroll are excluded from federal income tax and from Social Security and Medicare tax, but California adds them back to state wages; contributions made directly are deductible federally and not on the state return; and the account’s interest, dividends and capital gains are taxable each year on the California return, as if it were an ordinary brokerage account. The employer’s contribution is California wages too.
| Tax | Through payroll | Direct contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Federal income tax saved (24%) | $2,100 | $2,100 |
| Social Security and Medicare saved (7.65%) | $669 | $0 |
| California income tax saved (9.3%) | $0 | $0 |
| California SDI saved (1.3%) | $0 (SDI wages are not reduced) | $0 |
| Total saved | $2,769 | $2,100 |
Two consequences. Contribute through payroll where possible, since the FICA saving is only available that way. And hold the HSA’s investments in funds that throw off little taxable income, a total market index fund rather than a bond fund or a dividend fund, because every distribution is a line on the California return. Keep the brokerage’s annual statements; the state return needs the HSA’s dividend and gain figures every year, and the gain on a sale decades later needs a cost basis.
Prescriptions and the preventive drug list
On a PPO, a maintenance prescription is a $10 to $50 copay from the first fill. On a traditional HDHP, the full negotiated price applies until the deductible is met, which for an insulin, a biologic or a brand-name inhaler can mean $300 to $1,200 a month in the first quarter. Federal rules let HDHPs cover a list of preventive drugs, statins, blood-pressure medications, insulin, antidepressants, asthma controllers and several others, before the deductible, and most large San Diego employers’ plans use that safe harbor; the plan’s “preventive drug list” is a document worth reading before enrolling. California’s 2026 insulin cost-sharing cap applies to state-regulated plans and limits what a member pays per fill, but self-insured employer plans, which cover most workers at large companies, are governed by federal law and may not be bound by it. For a household with a monthly specialty drug, the PPO is often right regardless of the premium gap.
Pregnancy: the one event that settles the choice for a year
A San Diego hospital birth bills $18,000 to $35,000 for a vaginal delivery and $30,000 to $55,000 for a cesarean before negotiated discounts, and the newborn’s own charges, which start at birth, go against the family deductible. A family on an HDHP with a $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum will pay the full $7,000 in the birth year, almost certainly; the same family on a PPO with a $500 per-admission copay and a $4,000 maximum pays somewhere between those figures. Add the premium difference and the employer HSA contribution, and the HDHP is often still cheaper or close; but the year is the one to run the full-year calculation carefully, and the one to make sure the HSA, or the emergency fund, holds the maximum in January. A pregnancy planned for 2027 is also a reason to choose the plan during the November 2026 open enrollment with the birth year in view.
Chronic conditions and the year the HDHP loses
A household member with a condition that produces $15,000 or more of allowed charges a year, diabetes with complications, MS, Crohn’s, a child in weekly therapy, will reach the out-of-pocket maximum on either plan. The comparison then reduces to premiums plus maximums plus the HSA contribution, and the HDHP’s higher maximum is the decisive term. Using the figures from the main comparison: HDHP premium $2,400 plus maximum $7,000 less employer HSA $2,000 is $7,400; PPO premium $6,800 plus maximum $4,000 is $10,800. The HDHP still wins on money, by $3,400, and the HSA’s tax saving adds more. Where it loses is on cash flow and on networks: a specialist at UC San Diego or Rady who is in the PPO network and not in the HDHP’s narrower one is worth more than $3,400 to the family that needs them. Check the specific doctors, not the plan’s name.
The last quarter of the year
Deductibles reset on January 1 for calendar-year plans, which makes the fourth quarter the time to act. A family that has met its HDHP maximum should schedule every deferred procedure, the knee MRI, the dermatology visit, the second child’s orthodontic consult, before December 31, when they are free. A family that has not met the deductible should, where it is safe, defer elective care into January so that the spending counts against next year’s deductible rather than disappearing into this year’s. And a household switching from an HDHP to a PPO at open enrollment, or the reverse, should remember that the HSA balance stays and remains spendable; only new contributions stop when HDHP coverage ends.
The HSA at 65 and the Medicare trap
After 65 the HSA becomes a general retirement account: withdrawals for anything are taxed as ordinary income with no penalty, and withdrawals for medical costs, including Medicare Part B and D premiums, long-term care insurance premiums and the gaps in Medicare, remain tax-free. A San Diego couple who invested the HSA from 35 to 65 may enter retirement with $300,000 to $500,000 of medical money. The trap is enrollment: Medicare Part A is retroactive up to six months from the application date, and HSA contributions made during months of Medicare coverage are excess contributions. Anyone working past 65 on an employer HDHP who intends to claim Social Security or enroll in Medicare should stop HSA contributions six months before the application and prorate the year’s limit.
Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most
- Choosing by premium alone. The worst-year figure is premium plus maximum minus deposit; compute it.
- Taking the HDHP and not funding the HSA. That is a high-deductible plan with no upside.
- Deducting HSA contributions on the California return, or forgetting to report the account’s earnings to the state.
- Skipping needed care to protect the deductible. A $400 visit avoided becomes a $4,000 admission.
- Contributing to an HSA while a spouse has a general-purpose FSA or while covered by TRICARE or Medi-Cal, which disqualifies the contribution.
- Leaving the dependent-care FSA unused with a child in daycare.
The one-paragraph version
Add up premiums, the expected cost of care and the employer’s HSA contribution for a typical year and a bad year on each plan, with your actual doctors checked against each network. Choose the HDHP if it wins both years and you can hold the full deductible in cash by January; contribute to the HSA through payroll, invest it in an index fund, pay small bills from checking and keep the receipts. Choose the PPO if a pregnancy, a specialty drug or a specialist outside the HDHP network is in the year ahead. Revisit every November, because the plans, the premiums and the household change.
Leave a Reply