| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Rule of thumb | 10 to 12 times income; usually too little for a San Diego household with a mortgage |
| Better method | Debts plus income replacement plus mortgage or rent plus education, less savings and existing coverage |
| Median San Diego County home price | $925,000 to $962,000 (mid-2026) |
| Median two-bedroom rent | About $3,700 a month |
| Infant childcare, center-based | About $1,700 a month |
| Social Security survivor benefit, child under 18 | 75% of the deceased’s full benefit, per child, up to a family maximum of about 150% to 180% |
| VA Dependency and Indemnity Compensation, 2026 | About $1,700 a month to a surviving spouse, plus amounts per child |
| SGLI maximum | $500,000 |
| Replacing a stay-at-home parent’s work in San Diego | $40,000 to $60,000 a year |
| Typical result for a two-earner family with a mortgage | $1 million to $2 million per earner, in 20- or 30-year term |
Rules of thumb get you to the right order of magnitude. Your balance sheet gets you to the right number. In San Diego the two diverge more than in most places, because the largest item the survivors face, housing, is two to three times the national figure, and because the help the public system provides, Social Security survivor benefits, is sized for a national cost of living. A $110,000 earner’s family here needs more coverage than the same family in Kansas City, and the ten-times rule produces the same $1.1 million for both.
This guide works the number for a San Diego household item by item: what the money must pay for, what the survivors will already receive, what to subtract, and how the answer changes for a stay-at-home parent, a single parent, a military family, a business owner and a blended family. Figures are for 2026, and the method is the same whether the result is $300,000 or $3 million.
Why the rules of thumb fail here
Ten times income assumes the survivors can live on a 4% draw from the lump sum plus whatever they earn, in a place where a modest house costs $300,000. Apply it to a Clairemont couple earning $110,000 each with a $900,000 mortgage: $1.1 million pays off the mortgage and leaves $200,000, which is three years of the lost salary. The survivor is then a single parent carrying a San Diego household on one income with no cushion. The rule is not wrong so much as calibrated for somewhere else. The method below replaces it with the survivors’ actual budget.
The method: four needs, two offsets
Add four things, subtract two, and insure the result.
1. Debts that must be cleared
Credit cards, car loans, student loans the survivor is liable for, a business loan the spouse co-signed. In California, debts taken on during a marriage are generally community debts, so a card in one spouse’s name can still be collected from the survivor’s share of community property. Federal student loans are discharged at death; private ones often are not. Add funeral and final expenses, $10,000 to $20,000 in San Diego County.
2. The mortgage, or a decade of rent
The decision is whether the family should be able to stay. For homeowners, the cleanest answer is the full mortgage balance, so the survivor owns the house outright and the largest monthly cost disappears. For renters, the equivalent is enough to cover rent for long enough that the survivor is not forced to move in the worst year: ten years of a $3,700 two-bedroom is $444,000, or five years is $222,000 if the family would plausibly relocate. Military families should count the end of the housing allowance: the survivor of an active-duty member receives housing allowance for a year, then nothing.
3. Income replacement
Decide how many years of the lost income the family needs, and what share. A common frame: replace 60% to 70% of take-home pay (the deceased’s own consumption is gone) until the youngest child finishes college, and a smaller share afterward if the survivor would not otherwise reach retirement with enough. A 36-year-old earning $110,000 with take-home of about $82,000 and a two-year-old child needs roughly 65% of $82,000 for 20 years: about $1.07 million in today’s dollars, which a lump sum invested in a balanced portfolio can supply with inflation adjustments.
4. Education and childcare
Childcare is the item that surprises single surviving parents. A San Diego infant in center care costs about $1,700 a month, a toddler $1,500, a preschooler $1,300; a survivor who has to keep working full time faces $60,000 to $80,000 of care before transitional kindergarten at four. For college, in-state tuition and fees at a UC campus run about $15,000 a year and at a CSU campus about $8,000, plus living costs; $100,000 to $150,000 per child funds a UC degree with housing. Add the amount you would want the children to have, not the amount a brochure says college costs.
Offset A: what the survivors will receive
- Social Security survivor benefits. Each child under 18 (19 if still in high school) receives 75% of the deceased parent’s full retirement benefit, and a surviving spouse caring for a child under 16 receives 75% as well, subject to a family maximum of roughly 150% to 180% of the full benefit. For a worker with a full benefit of $3,000 a month, a family with two young children receives about $5,000 a month until the children age out, which is worth several hundred thousand dollars over 15 years. The spouse’s own benefit stops when the youngest turns 16 and resumes at 60. Check your own figure on the Social Security statement at ssa.gov; it is the single largest offset for most families.
- Military survivor benefits. SGLI pays up to $500,000. The VA’s Dependency and Indemnity Compensation pays a surviving spouse about $1,700 a month in 2026, tax-free, plus about $420 per child, for a service-connected death, and the Survivor Benefit Plan continues a share of a retiree’s pension. The death gratuity is $100,000, paid within days.
- Employer group life, typically one or two times salary.
- Existing savings and investments, excluding the retirement accounts the survivor will need for their own retirement.
Offset B: the survivor’s own earning power
If the survivor would keep working at $90,000, the income replacement need is for the lost income only, as calculated. If the survivor would stop working for a period, add that income too. If the survivor is a stay-at-home parent who would return to work, assume a realistic salary and a year of transition.
The San Diego worked example
| Item | Amount, per earner |
|---|---|
| Debts and final expenses | $45,000 |
| Pay off the mortgage | $900,000 |
| Replace 65% of take-home for 20 years | $1,070,000 |
| Childcare to age 5 and a UC degree | $190,000 |
| Total needs | $2,205,000 |
| Less Social Security survivor benefits (about $4,500 a month for 14 years, discounted) | −$620,000 |
| Less employer group life (two times salary) | −$220,000 |
| Less non-retirement savings | −$60,000 |
| Coverage to buy, per earner | About $1,300,000 |
At 36 and in good health, $1.3 million of 30-year term costs about $85 a month for her and $105 for him. Most couples who run this calculation are surprised twice: by the size of the number and by how little it costs.
Three ways to compute income replacement, compared
The method above estimates income replacement as a share of take-home pay for a fixed number of years. Two other approaches are common, and running all three shows how much the answer depends on the question asked.
| Method | Calculation | Result | What it assumes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Multiple of income | 10 to 12 times gross | $1,100,000 to $1,320,000 | Covers everything with one number; ignores housing costs and offsets |
| Needs-based (this guide) | 65% of take-home for 20 years, undiscounted | $1,070,000 | Survivors invest the sum and draw it down; returns offset inflation |
| Human life value | Present value of after-tax earnings to 67, growing 3% a year, discounted at 5%, less the deceased’s own consumption | About $1,900,000 | Replaces the full economic value of a career; usually the upper bound |
For most families the needs-based figure, added to the mortgage, education and debts, is the right target; the multiple-of-income rule is the floor and the human life value is the ceiling. A household that can afford the ceiling at a few extra dollars a month loses nothing by buying it.
Why a million dollars is not twenty years of $50,000
A lump sum invested earns a return while it is drawn down, and the withdrawals need to rise with inflation. The two effects roughly cancel at a 5% nominal return and 3% inflation, which is why the needs-based method simply multiplies years by the annual need. The table shows how long a sum lasts under those assumptions when a fixed real amount is withdrawn each year; it is also the table that shows a survivor how to think about the money once it arrives.
| Lump sum | $40,000 a year | $55,000 a year | $70,000 a year |
|---|---|---|---|
| $500,000 | 14 | 10 | 7 |
| $750,000 | 23 | 15 | 11 |
| $1,000,000 | 35 | 22 | 16 |
| $1,500,000 | Indefinitely | 40 | 27 |
A survivor who receives $1 million and needs $55,000 a year on top of their own income has about 22 years, which for a 36-year-old with a toddler is the right horizon. The same million at $70,000 a year lasts 16, which is why the childcare line in the early years matters: it pushes the annual need up precisely when the horizon is longest.
The survivor’s housing decision
The method assumes the mortgage is paid off. That is the safe assumption, but not always the best use of the money. A surviving spouse with a 2021 mortgage at 2.75% on a Clairemont house may be better off keeping the loan and investing the insurance proceeds, since the loan costs less than a Treasury bill pays; a survivor with a 2024 loan at 6.5% should pay it down. Proposition 13 adds a local reason to keep the house: the assessed value does not change at a spouse’s death, so property tax stays at the 2021 level, while any replacement home in the county would be assessed at today’s price. The policy should be sized to allow the payoff; the survivor decides at the time, with a fee-only planner, whether to make it.
Coordinating with the rest of the plan
Life insurance is one of three protections against lost income, and the sizing should reflect the other two. The emergency fund covers the first months after any shock and should not be counted as an offset, since the survivors will need it for exactly that. Disability coverage handles the far more common event of a living earner who cannot work; a household that has sized life insurance carefully and has no long-term disability coverage has insured the smaller risk. California’s State Disability Insurance pays up to $1,765 a week for a year, and Paid Family Leave gives a surviving spouse nothing, which is another reason the life policy carries the first year’s costs in full.
If the number is more than you can pay for
The full figure for a two-earner San Diego family is often $150 to $200 a month combined, which some budgets cannot absorb this year. The order of priorities: insure both earners for the mortgage or rent and ten years of income first, even if that is $700,000 rather than $1.3 million; use a 20-year term rather than 30 to cut the premium by a third; take the free employer coverage and any cheap supplemental tiers under 45; and add a second policy in two or three years when the pay rise arrives. Partial coverage bought now at a young age costs less, over the whole period, than full coverage bought at 45, and a family insured for $700,000 is in a different world from one insured for nothing.
The stay-at-home parent
A parent who earns nothing produces services the survivor would have to buy: full-time childcare, after-school care, transport, household management. In San Diego those run $40,000 to $60,000 a year until the children are in middle school, and the surviving earner may also want to work less for a period. Insure the stay-at-home parent for $500,000 to $800,000 in a term that runs to the youngest child’s teens; at 34 that is about $25 to $40 a month. Families that insure only the earner have insured the wrong half of the risk for the years when the children are small.
The single parent
With no second income to fall back on, the method’s income replacement line becomes the children’s entire support, and the policy needs a structure as much as a number. The money must go to a trust or a custodian under California’s Uniform Transfers to Minors Act, never to the children directly, with a named guardian in a will and a named trustee who will manage the money, who need not be the same person. A single parent earning $80,000 with two children under ten typically needs $800,000 to $1.2 million, which at 38 costs about $50 to $80 a month in a 20-year term.
The military family
Start from the offsets, which are larger than civilians receive: $500,000 of SGLI, the $100,000 death gratuity, DIC of about $1,700 a month plus child amounts for a service-connected death, a year of housing allowance, TRICARE for the survivors, and education benefits for the spouse and children under the Fry Scholarship and transferred GI Bill. For an E-6 family in Santee with two children, those cover roughly $900,000 to $1.1 million of a $1.5 million need. The gap, $400,000 to $600,000, is the commercial term policy to buy while serving, and the reason to buy it now rather than at separation is that it survives the end of SGLI and is priced on health, not on deployment. The term life guide covers SGLI and VGLI in detail.
The business owner
A self-employed electrician in Vista or a two-partner dental practice in Encinitas has two needs beyond the family’s. A policy sized to the business’s debts, often co-signed personally, so that the family is not left paying a truck loan or a lease. And, with a partner, a buy-sell agreement funded by life insurance on each partner, so that the survivor’s family is bought out at a fair price rather than inheriting half of a business they cannot run. The buy-sell policy is owned by the business or the other partner, sized to each partner’s share of the business’s value, and separate from the family policy.
The blended family and community property
Second marriages with children from the first raise the question of who is being provided for, and California’s community property rules shape the answer. A policy bought during the marriage with community funds belongs half to the spouse regardless of the beneficiary form, so naming children from a first marriage as sole beneficiaries invites a claim for half. The usual structure is two policies: one for the spouse, one for the children from the earlier marriage, with the second paid from separate funds or with the spouse’s written consent to the designation. A trust as beneficiary can direct the money precisely; an attorney should draft it.
How much on a child
Almost none. A child produces no income to replace; the only cost at a child’s death is the funeral, and a $10,000 to $25,000 child rider on a parent’s policy, at a dollar or two a month, covers it. Policies sold on children as “investments” or to “lock in insurability” are the expensive form of a cheap need; the money belongs in a 529 or an index fund.
Laddering to match a falling need
The need calculated above is highest today and falls every year, as the mortgage shrinks, the children age, and savings grow. One large 30-year policy covers the whole period at the whole amount, which is simple and slightly wasteful. Two or three policies with staggered terms match the curve: for the Clairemont earner, $700,000 for 30 years (the mortgage and the long tail) plus $600,000 for 15 years (the childcare and early-years income), which costs about 15% less than $1.3 million for 30 years and can be reduced further by dropping a policy once the need has clearly passed.
When to recalculate
Rerun the method at each of these: a marriage, a birth, a home purchase or refinance, a large pay change, a move in or out of the military, a business started, a child leaving home, a mortgage paid off, and an inheritance. Most families find the number rises through their thirties and falls through their fifties, and that the policy bought at 30 can be reduced at 50 and dropped at 60, when savings and a paid-off house have replaced it. The method also answers the opposite question, whether you have too much; a retired couple in Point Loma with no mortgage and $1.5 million in retirement accounts should let the term expire.
Four San Diego households, sized
| Household | Needs | Offsets | Coverage to buy | Monthly cost (healthy, preferred class) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single nurse at Sharp, 38, two children, renting in La Mesa, $95,000 | Rent 10 years $360,000; income 65% for 16 years $750,000; childcare and college $200,000; debts $25,000 | Social Security survivors about $4,200 a month for 12 years ($450,000); group life $190,000; savings $30,000 | About $700,000, 20-year term, to a trust | About $45 |
| Navy E-6, 31, spouse at home, two children, Santee, buying with a VA loan | Mortgage $620,000; income 65% for 18 years $700,000; college $200,000 | SGLI $500,000; death gratuity $100,000; DIC about $2,500 a month ($350,000); housing allowance one year $48,000 | About $550,000 for him, 20-year term; $500,000 on the spouse | About $28 and $24 |
| Biotech scientist, 44, married, one teenager, Carmel Valley, $210,000, $1.1 million mortgage | Mortgage $1,100,000; income 60% for 10 years $900,000; college $150,000; debts $30,000 | Social Security about $3,800 a month for 4 years ($170,000); group life $420,000; savings and vested stock $400,000 | About $1,200,000, 15-year term | About $95 |
| Retired couple, 68, Point Loma, no mortgage, $1.5 million in retirement accounts | Final expenses | Everything | None; let the old term policy expire | $0 |
What the final figure costs
The number the method produces is only useful if it is affordable, so the last step is to price it. Term life is cheap at the ages when the need is largest, and the table shows what the common San Diego figures cost for a healthy non-smoker in the preferred class, which most applicants under 40 with normal weight and blood pressure receive.
| Coverage | Age 30 | Age 35 | Age 40 | Age 45 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $750,000 | $30 to $38 | $33 to $42 | $48 to $60 | $80 to $100 |
| $1,000,000 | $38 to $48 | $42 to $55 | $62 to $78 | $105 to $130 |
| $1,500,000 | $55 to $70 | $62 to $80 | $90 to $115 | $155 to $195 |
| $2,000,000 | $72 to $92 | $80 to $105 | $120 to $150 | $205 to $260 |
A 30-year term costs 40% to 60% more than the 20-year figures above, and a woman’s premium runs 15% to 25% below a man’s at every age. The table makes the earlier point concrete: the difference between the $700,000 a family thinks it can afford and the $1.3 million the method says it needs is about $25 a month at 32. Few budgets fail on that margin, and the household that waits until 45 to buy the right amount pays nearly three times as much for it.
Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most
- Using ten times income for a household whose housing costs are twice the national figure.
- Insuring the earner and not the stay-at-home parent.
- Forgetting Social Security survivor benefits, which can offset half the need, or counting them twice.
- Treating SGLI as the whole answer for a military family in this county.
- Naming children directly instead of a trust or custodian.
- Never recalculating, so that a policy bought at 30 is still in force at 62 and the mortgage-sized need at 40 was never covered.
The one-paragraph version
Add the housing payoff or ten years of rent, income replacement at 65% of take-home for the years until the youngest is independent, education, and debts; subtract liquid savings and any group or military coverage that will still be there; round up; and buy that amount of level term for each earner and $500,000 or so for a stay-at-home parent. Price it, which at 30 to 40 is usually under $100 a month for the whole answer, and recalculate at every birth, purchase, promotion and move. The number is almost always larger than the rule of thumb and almost always affordable.
Leave a Reply