| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Contribution limit | $7,500; $8,600 at 50 or older; shared with any Roth IRA |
| Deduction if you have a retirement plan at work, single | Full below $81,000 of modified AGI; phased out to $91,000 |
| Deduction if you have a plan at work, married filing jointly | Full below $129,000; phased out to $149,000 |
| Deduction if you have no plan but your spouse does | Full below $242,000; phased out to $252,000 |
| Deduction if neither of you has a plan at work | Full, at any income |
| Tax on withdrawals | Ordinary income, federal and California (for residents) |
| Early withdrawal penalty before 59½ | 10% federal plus 2.5% California, with exceptions |
| Required minimum distributions | From age 73; 75 for those born in 1960 or later |
| Qualified charitable distributions from 70½ | Up to about $111,000 a year, excluded from income |
| Saver’s credit, 2026 | 10% to 50% of up to $2,000 contributed, for AGI up to $40,125 single or $80,250 joint |
The traditional IRA was the original individual retirement account, and for most San Diego professionals it has become a supporting player: the deduction that made it attractive phases out at modest incomes for anyone with a 401(k) at work, and the Roth has taken over as the IRA of choice. But the account still does four jobs that nothing else does as well. It is the deductible account for workers with no plan at work, which in San Diego includes a large share of the self-employed, small-business employees, gig workers and part-timers. It is where old 401(k)s go when people change jobs. It is the vehicle for the backdoor Roth. And it is the account from which retirees make tax-free gifts to charity. This guide covers each of those jobs, the 2026 rules, the California differences, and the decisions around rollovers and withdrawals that cost people the most.
How it works
You contribute up to $7,500 a year of earned income, deduct the contribution on your tax return if you qualify, and the money grows without tax until withdrawn. Withdrawals are ordinary income, taxed by the federal government and, for a California resident, by the state at rates up to 9.3% and beyond. Withdrawals before 59½ carry a 10% federal penalty, and California adds its own 2.5% penalty, unless an exception applies. From 73, or 75 for people born in 1960 or later, a minimum amount must be withdrawn each year whether it is needed or not.
The deduction is the whole point, and it is available in full only to people who are not “covered” by a retirement plan at work, or who are covered but earn under the limits in the table. Covered means the box on your W-2 is checked: you or your employer contributed to a 401(k), 403(b), SIMPLE, SEP, pension or the Thrift Savings Plan during the year. A governmental 457(b) plan, which many City, County and school district employees have, does not count as coverage for this purpose, which gives those employees an unusual advantage covered below.
Who gets the deduction in San Diego
| Who | Covered at work? | Modified AGI | Deduction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-employed real estate agent, Carlsbad, no retirement plan | No | $140,000 | Full $7,500 |
| Barista with no employer plan, single | No | $38,000 | Full, plus a saver’s credit |
| Nurse with a 403(b), single | Yes | $98,000 | None (above $91,000); non-deductible or Roth instead |
| Teacher with a 403(b), single | Yes | $78,000 | Full (below $81,000) |
| County employee with a 457(b) only, single | No (457(b) does not count) | $120,000 | Full $7,500 |
| Stay-at-home spouse, partner has a 401(k), joint | No, spouse yes | $200,000 | Full (below $242,000) |
| Engineer with a 401(k), married, joint | Yes | $230,000 | None; backdoor Roth instead |
| Navy E-6 contributing to the TSP, married | Yes | $95,000 | Full (below $129,000) |
The pattern: the deduction belongs to people without a workplace plan at any income, to moderate earners with a plan, and to non-working spouses of high earners. For the typical two-income professional couple with two 401(k)s, it is gone by $149,000 of joint income, and the IRA’s role becomes the backdoor.
Deductible, non-deductible, or Roth
If the deduction is available, the question is the one in the Roth versus traditional guide: deduct now at today’s combined rate, or pay now and withdraw tax-free later. For a San Diego self-employed earner at 24% federal and 9.3% California, the deduction is worth $2,500 on a $7,500 contribution this year, and the money will be taxed at retirement rates; for a barista in the 12% bracket, the Roth is clearly better and the saver’s credit applies to either.
If the deduction is not available, a non-deductible traditional IRA contribution is almost never the right endpoint. The money goes in after tax and the earnings are taxed as ordinary income on withdrawal, which is worse than a taxable brokerage account for stock funds, whose gains would be taxed at capital gains rates. A non-deductible contribution makes sense only as step one of the backdoor Roth, converted within days.
The 457(b) advantage for public employees
Because a governmental 457(b) is not a “retirement plan at work” for IRA deduction purposes, a City of San Diego, County, SANDAG or school district employee whose only plan is a 457(b) can deduct a full traditional IRA contribution at any income. Most such employees also have a defined-benefit pension, CalPERS, SDCERS or CalSTRS, which does count as coverage, so the advantage applies mainly to part-time and contract public employees who are in the 457(b) but not the pension. For them, it is a $7,500 deduction on top of the 457(b)’s $24,500.
The spousal IRA
A non-working spouse can contribute $7,500 to their own traditional IRA on the working spouse’s income, and deduct it in full if the couple’s modified AGI is under $242,000, because the non-working spouse is not covered by a plan. A military spouse between jobs after a move, or a parent at home with young children, has a $7,500 deductible contribution available every year, worth $2,500 in tax to a couple at 33.3%. If the couple prefers Roth, the same spousal contribution can go to a Roth IRA instead, subject to the Roth income limits.
The saver’s credit
Lower-income savers get a tax credit on top of the deduction: 50%, 20% or 10% of the first $2,000 contributed to an IRA or workplace plan, for 2026 adjusted gross income up to $40,125 single, $60,187 head of household or $80,250 joint, with the 50% rate at the lowest incomes. A single worker earning $30,000 who contributes $2,000 to a traditional IRA deducts $2,000 and receives a $1,000 credit, so the contribution costs about $760 after tax. The credit is non-refundable, so it helps only people with federal tax to offset, and students and dependents are excluded. From 2027 it becomes the saver’s match, a federal deposit into the account rather than a credit, which will reach more people.
Rollovers: where old 401(k)s go
The traditional IRA is the default destination for a 401(k) when someone leaves a job, and the decision deserves more thought than it usually gets. The choices are four: leave the money in the old plan (allowed above $7,000), roll it to the new employer’s plan, roll it to a traditional IRA, or cash out, which is almost always wrong (tax, 10% federal and 2.5% California penalties, and a lost decade of compounding).
| Factor | Leave it or move to new 401(k) | Roll to a traditional IRA |
|---|---|---|
| Investment choice and cost | Limited to the plan menu; large plans often have institutional funds under 0.05% | Anything; index funds at similar cost; also access to Treasuries and CDs |
| Creditor protection in California | Full, under federal ERISA law | Full in bankruptcy up to about $1.7 million; outside bankruptcy, California protects an IRA only to the extent needed for support |
| Penalty-free access after leaving a job at 55 or older | Yes, from that plan | No; 59½ applies |
| Backdoor Roth | Unaffected | Blocked by the pro-rata rule until the IRA is emptied |
| Employer stock with large gains | Net unrealized appreciation treatment available | Lost |
| Consolidation and simplicity | One account per employer | One account for life |
| Required minimum distributions while still working | Delayed in the current employer’s plan | Required from 73 or 75 |
For a San Diego professional who expects to use the backdoor Roth, the answer is usually to move the old 401(k) to the new employer’s plan, or to leave it where it is if the plan is good. For someone with no new plan, the rollover IRA is right, and the pro-rata consequence is accepted. For anyone in a profession with liability exposure, physicians, contractors, landlords, the ERISA protection of a 401(k) is a real reason to leave the money in a plan, since California’s protection for IRAs outside bankruptcy is weaker than most states’.
Mechanics: ask for a direct rollover, with the check made out to the new custodian, which avoids the 20% mandatory withholding that applies to a check made out to you. An indirect rollover must be completed within 60 days and, for IRA-to-IRA moves, is allowed once every 12 months across all your IRAs; trustee-to-trustee transfers are unlimited.
Early withdrawals and the exceptions
Before 59½, a withdrawal is taxed as income and penalized 10% federally and 2.5% by California, so a $20,000 withdrawal by a San Diegan at 24% and 9.3% costs about $9,200 in tax and penalties. The exceptions to the penalty (the income tax still applies):
- Up to $10,000, lifetime, for a first home purchase, defined as no ownership in the prior two years.
- Qualified higher education costs for you, a spouse, children or grandchildren.
- Unreimbursed medical expenses above 7.5% of AGI.
- Health insurance premiums while receiving unemployment benefits for 12 consecutive weeks.
- Up to $5,000 within a year of a birth or adoption, per child.
- One $1,000 emergency withdrawal a year, repayable within three years.
- Up to $10,000 for a victim of domestic abuse.
- Substantially equal periodic payments under section 72(t), which commit you to a schedule for five years or until 59½.
- Total and permanent disability; death; an IRS levy; qualified reservist distributions for a service member called to active duty for more than 179 days.
California generally follows the federal exceptions for its 2.5% penalty. The first-home exception is the one San Diegans ask about most, and $10,000 is a small part of a down payment on a $1 million home; a Roth IRA’s contributions, withdrawable without limit, are the better source.
Required minimum distributions
From the year you turn 73 (75 if born in 1960 or later), the IRS requires a withdrawal each year equal to the prior December 31 balance divided by a life-expectancy factor: about 3.8% at 73, 4.1% at 75, 5.0% at 80, 6.8% at 85. The first RMD can be delayed to April 1 of the following year, which forces two in one year and is rarely wise. Missing an RMD carries a 25% excise tax on the shortfall, reduced to 10% if corrected within two years. RMDs are taxed by California for residents, count toward Medicare premium surcharges, and raise the taxed share of Social Security, which is the chain of consequences that makes Roth conversions in the early retirement years so valuable for households with large traditional balances.
Qualified charitable distributions
From 70½, an IRA owner can send up to about $111,000 a year directly from the IRA to a charity, and the amount is excluded from income entirely, counts toward the RMD, and never appears in AGI, so it does not affect Medicare surcharges or Social Security taxation. For a retired San Diegan who gives to a church, the San Diego Food Bank, Rady Children’s or a university and who takes the standard deduction, the QCD is strictly better than writing a check: a $10,000 gift by check saves nothing at the standard deduction, while a $10,000 QCD saves the federal and California tax on $10,000 of RMD, about $3,100 for a couple at 22% and 9.3%. The check must go from the custodian to the charity; a withdrawal followed by a donation does not qualify. Donor-advised funds and private foundations are not eligible recipients.
Inherited traditional IRAs
A spouse who inherits can treat the IRA as their own. Most other heirs must empty the account within ten years and, if the original owner had reached RMD age, take annual distributions in years one through nine as well. Every dollar is ordinary income to the heir, federally and, for a California resident heir, at state rates. A child in their peak earning years who inherits $500,000 pays tax on it at 24% to 32% federal plus 9.3% California, which can consume a third of the account; the parent who converted part of it to Roth during low-income years leaves far more. Beneficiary designations control the account regardless of the will, and should be reviewed after every marriage, divorce and birth; California’s community property rules mean a spouse generally has a claim to half of contributions made during the marriage, so naming someone other than the spouse requires the spouse’s written consent at most custodians.
What to hold in it
A traditional IRA is the right home for the assets that are taxed worst in a taxable account and gain nothing from the Roth: bonds, bond funds, CDs and REITs, whose income is ordinary either way. A household holding a three-fund portfolio across accounts often puts the bond share in the traditional IRA or 401(k), the stock index funds in the Roth, and international stock funds in the taxable account for the foreign tax credit. Treasury bills are an exception: their California exemption is wasted inside any IRA, so they belong in the taxable account.
CalSavers and the state auto-IRA
California requires every employer with at least one employee and no retirement plan to enroll workers in CalSavers, the state’s automatic IRA program, at a default contribution of 5% of pay rising by 1% a year to 8%. The default account is a Roth IRA, and workers can elect a traditional IRA instead or opt out. CalSavers’ funds cost more than a brokerage IRA’s, and the contribution limit is the same $7,500, so a worker who can manage an account should consider opening a traditional or Roth IRA at a brokerage and opting out; but for the many San Diego restaurant, retail and small-office workers who would otherwise save nothing, the automatic 5% is the single most useful feature of the program, and the Roth default is right for their bracket.
Three San Diego households
| Household | Situation | Use of the traditional IRA | Annual tax effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-employed landscaper, 41, Lakeside, $92,000 net, married, spouse at home | No plan at work; wants the deduction and simplicity | Deductible IRA $7,500 for each spouse (spousal for the second); adds a SEP or solo 401(k) when income allows | $15,000 deducted; about $4,300 saved at 22% and 6% to 8% |
| Biotech scientist, 38, Sorrento Valley, $150,000, laid off with a $210,000 401(k) | Needs a home for the old plan; expects a new job and the backdoor Roth | Leaves the 401(k) in the old plan for now; rolls it into the new employer’s plan on hire; opens a traditional IRA only for the backdoor | Preserves ERISA protection and a clean backdoor |
| Retired couple, 74 and 72, La Jolla, $1.4 million traditional IRA, give $15,000 a year to charity | RMD of about $53,000; Medicare surcharge at the margin | $15,000 of the RMD sent as a QCD; converts $40,000 to Roth in years before the younger spouse’s RMDs start | Saves about $4,700 of tax on the QCD and keeps AGI under the next surcharge tier |
Opening and running one
- Check coverage and income against the table to see whether the deduction applies; if not, decide between the backdoor Roth and skipping the IRA.
- Open the account at Fidelity, Schwab or Vanguard, choosing “Traditional IRA” (or “Rollover IRA” for a 401(k) rollover; the two are functionally the same, but some plans accept roll-ins only from accounts that held plan money).
- Contribute by April 15 of the following year, designating the tax year.
- Invest, with bonds and bond funds first in line for this account.
- Claim the deduction on Schedule 1 of Form 1040; the California return follows automatically.
- If any contribution is non-deductible, file Form 8606 and keep it.
- Name beneficiaries and review them.
- At 70½, set up QCDs; at 73 or 75, calendar the RMD and consider conversions in the years before.
The phase-out arithmetic
Inside the phase-out range the deduction shrinks in proportion. A single nurse with a 403(b) and modified AGI of $86,000 is halfway through the $81,000 to $91,000 range, so half of a $7,500 contribution, $3,750, is deductible and the other half is not (the IRS rounds the deductible amount up to the nearest $10 and allows at least $200 if any deduction remains). The non-deductible half creates basis that must be tracked on Form 8606 for the rest of the account’s life, which is a nuisance most people would rather avoid; the cleaner choices at that income are a full Roth contribution, which is allowed at $86,000, or a larger 403(b) deferral to bring modified AGI under $81,000, which makes the whole IRA contribution deductible. A pre-tax deferral of $5,000 more at work turns a half-deductible IRA into a fully deductible one, and saves the tax on the $5,000 as well.
The sixty-day rule and the once-a-year rule
A distribution paid to you can be put back into an IRA within 60 days and treated as a rollover, which some people use as a short-term loan. Two restrictions make this dangerous. Only one IRA-to-IRA rollover of this kind is allowed in any 12-month period across all your IRAs; a second one is a taxable distribution and an excess contribution. And the 60 days are calendar days with no extension for weekends, mail delays or a brokerage’s processing time; a check deposited on day 61 is income, penalized, and cannot be undone. Direct transfers between custodians, where the money never touches your hands, are unlimited and carry none of this risk, and a 401(k)-to-IRA direct rollover is not counted against the once-a-year rule either. The sensible policy is never to take a check.
Converting a traditional IRA to Roth
Any amount of a traditional IRA can be converted to a Roth in any year, with the converted amount (less any basis) taxed as income federally and by California. The Roth versus traditional guide covers when that is worth doing: low-income years, early retirement before RMDs, a deployment year, or the years after leaving California. Two mechanics matter. A conversion cannot be reversed, so size it to the bracket and do it late in the year when income is known. And the tax should be paid from outside the IRA; converting $50,000 and withholding $15,000 for tax converts only $35,000 and, under 59½, penalizes the $15,000 as a distribution.
The calendar
Contributions for a tax year can be made from January 1 of that year until the filing deadline of the following April, without extensions, and must be designated for the correct year at the brokerage. Conversions count in the calendar year they occur. Required minimum distributions are due by December 31, except the first, which may be delayed to April 1. Qualified charitable distributions must leave the custodian by December 31 to count for the year, and custodians get slow in December. Recharacterizations and excess-contribution corrections are due by the extended filing deadline, October 15. A saver who contributes in January rather than April gains fifteen months of growth per contribution, which over a career is about a year’s worth of contributions for free.
The one-paragraph version
Deduct a traditional IRA contribution if you have no retirement plan at work, if your income is under the limits despite one, or if you are the non-working spouse of someone who has one. Otherwise, use it only as the first step of a backdoor Roth. Keep old 401(k)s in a plan unless the plan is poor, never take a rollover check, give to charity from the IRA after 70½, and convert to Roth in the low-income years before required distributions begin.
Mistakes that cost San Diegans the most
- Making non-deductible contributions and leaving them, which turns capital gains into ordinary income for no reason; convert them.
- Cashing out a 401(k) at a job change, with federal and California tax and 12.5% of combined penalties.
- Rolling an old 401(k) into an IRA the year before starting the backdoor Roth, which triggers the pro-rata rule.
- Taking an indirect rollover check and losing 20% to withholding until the next tax return.
- Missing a required minimum distribution and paying a 25% excise tax.
- Giving to charity by check from a taxable account after 70½ while taking RMDs, instead of a QCD.
- Forgetting the spousal IRA for a non-working spouse.
- Ignoring California’s weaker creditor protection for IRAs in a profession with liability exposure.
Leave a Reply